WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.212 --> 00:00:03.962
Can Gnosis turn Ethereum from a crypto-native settlement

2
00:00:03.962 --> 00:00:07.539
layer into real financial infrastructure for Europe

3
00:00:07.587 --> 00:00:10.966
without rebuilding the same gatekeepers decentralized

4
00:00:10.982 --> 00:00:13.072
finance was meant to replace?

5
00:00:23.724 --> 00:00:26.925
What do Gnosis, Gnosis Pay, Safe, and

6
00:00:26.973 --> 00:00:30.599
CoW Protocol reveal about the

7
00:00:30.599 --> 00:00:34.028
next phase of fintech startups Europe, B2B

8
00:00:34.028 --> 00:00:37.794
payments in Europe, embedded finance and infrastructure software?

9
00:00:38.018 --> 00:00:41.560
How should founders, venture capitalists, and operators in Germany, Austria, and

10
00:00:41.560 --> 00:00:45.326
Switzerland understand Dr. Friederike Ernst as co-founder

11
00:00:45.326 --> 00:00:49.060
of Gnosis, as a builder of Ethereum infrastructure,

12
00:00:49.636 --> 00:00:52.745
or as one of the European operators testing

13
00:00:53.242 --> 00:00:56.174
whether decentralized finance can become

14
00:00:56.623 --> 00:01:00.276
usable financial infrastructure. Hello and welcome everybody.

15
00:01:00.628 --> 00:01:04.073
Can decentralized finance become part of everyday payments,

16
00:01:04.137 --> 00:01:06.716
custody, and trading without losing the

17
00:01:06.716 --> 00:01:10.369
decentralization that made it worth building?

18
00:01:11.378 --> 00:01:15.047
Friederike, welcome to Startuprad.io. Thank you so much for having me.

19
00:01:15.512 --> 00:01:19.068
When someone searches for Gnosis today, what should they understand

20
00:01:19.068 --> 00:01:22.801
first? Ethereum infrastructure, decentralized finance,

21
00:01:22.993 --> 00:01:26.792
self-custody, crypto payments, or something else? All of the above,

22
00:01:27.226 --> 00:01:30.517
honestly. So we've built Ethereum infrastructure

23
00:01:30.822 --> 00:01:34.531
with Gnosis Chain. We've built DeFi with CoW and

24
00:01:34.531 --> 00:01:38.289
Safe, self-custody and crypto payments with Gnosis Pay.

25
00:01:38.385 --> 00:01:41.436
So no single label really captures it.

26
00:01:42.784 --> 00:01:46.494
What to understand first is kind of what really underpins it. It's

27
00:01:46.494 --> 00:01:50.251
really a set of values. So we do very strongly believe

28
00:01:50.251 --> 00:01:53.879
that people should be empowered with agency and

29
00:01:53.879 --> 00:01:57.570
choice over their money and their digital lives. So no one should be locked

30
00:01:58.051 --> 00:02:01.807
into systems. You should be able to leave. You should be able to take your

31
00:02:01.807 --> 00:02:04.680
assets and go elsewhere if you so choose.

32
00:02:06.012 --> 00:02:09.431
So we design systems that should be fair and

33
00:02:09.527 --> 00:02:12.801
non-extractive. And the rails themselves shouldn't

34
00:02:12.817 --> 00:02:16.557
rent-seek from the people using them. So if you look at the things that

35
00:02:16.589 --> 00:02:20.200
we've built, everything we've built is an expression of those values. And that's

36
00:02:20.200 --> 00:02:24.037
kind of what kind of corrals it all back together. What

37
00:02:24.278 --> 00:02:27.763
is the operating problem Gnosis is solving that

38
00:02:27.907 --> 00:02:31.600
most fintech founders and venture capitalists outside crypto still

39
00:02:31.600 --> 00:02:35.261
describe incorrectly? That's a fantastic question. So

40
00:02:36.642 --> 00:02:39.645
what I would point to is that kind of standard fintech

41
00:02:39.934 --> 00:02:42.776
and VC operators have a playbook

42
00:02:43.627 --> 00:02:46.903
that is extraction dressed as growth.

43
00:02:47.417 --> 00:02:51.062
So you acquire users cheaply, you lock them in,

44
00:02:51.608 --> 00:02:54.764
and then you milk them. So kind of with spreads and fees and data and

45
00:02:54.797 --> 00:02:58.434
switching costs and kind of retention really often

46
00:02:58.482 --> 00:03:02.087
means captivity. So the problem that we are

47
00:03:02.087 --> 00:03:05.933
solving is building finance that people choose, not finance

48
00:03:06.013 --> 00:03:09.827
that traps them in. So kind of products with no lock-in,

49
00:03:10.244 --> 00:03:14.058
you can leave anytime with your assets at no cost. Products

50
00:03:14.090 --> 00:03:17.839
you can own a piece of if you choose to as a stakeholder and

51
00:03:18.614 --> 00:03:22.436
not as inventory and products that people keep

52
00:03:22.436 --> 00:03:25.907
coming back to anyway because they're better and

53
00:03:26.068 --> 00:03:29.507
not because leaving is painful. And I think this is the part that

54
00:03:29.587 --> 00:03:33.202
outsiders often get wrong. They see crypto's

55
00:03:33.218 --> 00:03:36.930
volatility and assume that it's all about

56
00:03:37.219 --> 00:03:41.059
short-termism when the actual bet is exactly the opposite.

57
00:03:41.509 --> 00:03:45.205
So voluntary retention should beat forced retention and the

58
00:03:45.205 --> 00:03:48.996
value created for users compounds longer than the

59
00:03:48.996 --> 00:03:52.522
value extracted from them. Where did the early

60
00:03:52.618 --> 00:03:56.450
Ethereum ecosystem underestimate what it takes to build

61
00:03:56.450 --> 00:03:59.559
financial infrastructure for normal users, companies, and

62
00:03:59.640 --> 00:04:03.262
institutions? We were so green, which I think is why

63
00:04:03.327 --> 00:04:07.094
it's taken us so long. So censorship

64
00:04:07.094 --> 00:04:10.845
resistance, which really is at the base of Ethereum, makes user protection much,

65
00:04:10.941 --> 00:04:14.660
much harder. So the property that keeps the system credibly

66
00:04:14.660 --> 00:04:18.299
neutral also removes that safety net that everyone's already used to.

67
00:04:18.780 --> 00:04:22.226
So the irreversibility that you have as a feature

68
00:04:22.579 --> 00:04:26.234
for the settlement is very much a bug for humans. So

69
00:04:27.228 --> 00:04:30.884
what's way too easy is fat fingering and kind of falling for scams

70
00:04:31.060 --> 00:04:34.731
and there's no recourse, right? So kind of one wrong character in an address line,

71
00:04:34.747 --> 00:04:38.290
one phishing site, your money's gone and you have no chargeback, you have no

72
00:04:38.354 --> 00:04:42.186
fraud desk you can call. And banks solved this a really

73
00:04:42.282 --> 00:04:45.713
long time ago with policy engines, right? So kind of if you're sending

74
00:04:45.809 --> 00:04:49.598
€20,000 to a Nigerian account, they will damn well call you up

75
00:04:49.598 --> 00:04:53.235
and say, Joe, you sure? You sure about this? And you can tell them, oh

76
00:04:53.316 --> 00:04:57.115
yeah, absolutely. This is my buddy, he's a prince. And they

77
00:04:57.180 --> 00:05:01.020
will process your payment, but kind of like you will get a fair warning, right?

78
00:05:01.344 --> 00:05:05.027
So what we actually need to do is

79
00:05:05.384 --> 00:05:08.993
build rails with

80
00:05:09.025 --> 00:05:11.824
guardrails, which currently are still

81
00:05:12.762 --> 00:05:16.061
not there yet. So kind of what you build is, those

82
00:05:16.077 --> 00:05:19.571
protections kind of to fit into

83
00:05:19.619 --> 00:05:22.280
self-custody. So you have limits, delays, allowlists,

84
00:05:22.970 --> 00:05:26.672
co-signing kind of, and it can all live in the user's smart

85
00:05:26.672 --> 00:05:30.520
account, not with a custodian. But even if you're not

86
00:05:30.520 --> 00:05:34.238
here for self-custody, it's totally fine. Self-custody is not for everyone.

87
00:05:34.286 --> 00:05:37.957
It's about the optionality. So some people will want a custodian and

88
00:05:38.037 --> 00:05:41.724
that's totally fine too. What matters to me is that the choice

89
00:05:41.724 --> 00:05:45.563
exists. And custody is opted into and

90
00:05:46.238 --> 00:05:49.982
not the only choice. So the failure to

91
00:05:50.014 --> 00:05:53.565
me of TradFi was never really the custody itself.

92
00:05:54.256 --> 00:05:57.325
It's that there wasn't a choice and there was no alternative.

93
00:05:58.514 --> 00:06:02.274
What belief about decentralization did you hold in

94
00:06:02.274 --> 00:06:05.842
the early Gnosis years that reality forced you to

95
00:06:05.906 --> 00:06:09.616
revise? I think that decentralization is

96
00:06:09.616 --> 00:06:13.273
always king. It really isn't. So kind of there are absolutely scenarios

97
00:06:13.370 --> 00:06:16.963
where no recourse is exactly what you don't want. And I mean,

98
00:06:17.557 --> 00:06:20.990
talk about the scams and fat fingering issues that kind of we just talked about,

99
00:06:21.006 --> 00:06:24.584
right? So what matters to

100
00:06:24.632 --> 00:06:27.857
me now is the exit, not the absence of

101
00:06:27.905 --> 00:06:31.114
intermediaries. So kind of my revised belief would be

102
00:06:31.820 --> 00:06:35.333
decentralization's real value is being able to switch

103
00:06:35.445 --> 00:06:38.301
between service providers, even centralized ones,

104
00:06:38.959 --> 00:06:42.520
without lock-in. So decentralize the rails,

105
00:06:43.387 --> 00:06:46.996
not necessarily every service on top. And kind of if you have a neutral

106
00:06:46.996 --> 00:06:50.734
base layer with competing providers above it,

107
00:06:50.911 --> 00:06:54.039
you get both, right? Kind of you get convenience when you want it and you

108
00:06:54.039 --> 00:06:57.873
get freedom when you need it. Looking at Kalshi and

109
00:06:57.970 --> 00:07:01.643
other prediction markets, Gnosis started out as early

110
00:07:01.900 --> 00:07:05.511
as a prediction market. and then moved into broader

111
00:07:05.527 --> 00:07:09.220
Ethereum infrastructure. What decision rule guided that shift?

112
00:07:09.766 --> 00:07:13.186
Yeah, I'm still a little bit salty. So I think kind of like we were

113
00:07:13.234 --> 00:07:16.638
super early and Polymarket does very much use our framework. So kind of like it's

114
00:07:16.687 --> 00:07:20.364
built on the Gnosis Conditional Token framework as its

115
00:07:20.380 --> 00:07:24.073
backbone. Kalshi is centralized. So kind of for

116
00:07:24.073 --> 00:07:27.782
Kalshi, kind of it's, I don't have this sentiment so much, but

117
00:07:29.275 --> 00:07:32.631
yeah, I'm a little bit salty. I'm also happy that kind of Our,

118
00:07:33.370 --> 00:07:37.175
um, that our thesis that prediction markets would make

119
00:07:37.175 --> 00:07:40.643
it big was validated. Still sad it wasn't validated by us,

120
00:07:41.077 --> 00:07:44.256
um, but, uh, sometimes, uh, that's the way the

121
00:07:44.465 --> 00:07:48.174
cookie crumbles, right? How do you decide whether

122
00:07:48.318 --> 00:07:51.931
Gnosis should build something directly, support an ecosystem

123
00:07:51.931 --> 00:07:55.544
project, spin it out, or let the market

124
00:07:55.544 --> 00:07:57.567
solve it without you?

125
00:08:01.505 --> 00:08:05.299
I think I should point out first that we were absurdly early, right? Kind of

126
00:08:05.331 --> 00:08:08.604
we started, we actually launched our first

127
00:08:09.518 --> 00:08:12.935
smart contracts on Ethereum 2 or 3 weeks after

128
00:08:12.935 --> 00:08:16.240
Ethereum itself launched in the very first instance.

129
00:08:17.347 --> 00:08:20.860
I think we may be the oldest project still around and active

130
00:08:21.919 --> 00:08:25.399
on Ethereum. So you, You have to

131
00:08:25.623 --> 00:08:29.455
think about what Ethereum was back, what Ethereum was like

132
00:08:29.471 --> 00:08:33.238
back then, right? It was really bare bones. So our rule

133
00:08:33.238 --> 00:08:36.892
was really simple. If what you needed

134
00:08:37.165 --> 00:08:41.012
doesn't exist, you build it. And there was nothing there. So kind of

135
00:08:41.012 --> 00:08:44.490
there were no wallets, no exchanges, no tooling. And prediction

136
00:08:44.490 --> 00:08:48.193
markets needed infrastructure the ecosystem didn't have. And then

137
00:08:48.225 --> 00:08:51.736
kind of that's how we started building Safe, the

138
00:08:51.752 --> 00:08:54.580
largest smart wallet on Ethereum. That's how we built it.

139
00:08:55.592 --> 00:08:59.304
That's how we started building CoW, now the largest

140
00:08:59.304 --> 00:09:02.936
DEX aggregator on Ethereum. And they all began as internal

141
00:09:02.936 --> 00:09:06.712
needs and turned out to be actual businesses. And the

142
00:09:06.776 --> 00:09:10.456
ecosystem at the time needed them more than it needed prediction markets. What

143
00:09:10.456 --> 00:09:13.991
threshold tells you that a product is infrastructure

144
00:09:13.991 --> 00:09:17.269
software Europe can rely on rather than

145
00:09:19.767 --> 00:09:23.614
Good question. I think every company to some

146
00:09:23.662 --> 00:09:27.228
extent is pervaded by its founder's DNA, right? And

147
00:09:27.420 --> 00:09:30.601
Gnosis was very much founded by 3 German engineers and that's kind of

148
00:09:31.179 --> 00:09:34.954
what we're here for. So kind of we like building things when there

149
00:09:34.954 --> 00:09:38.214
are at least 2 things present, a conviction

150
00:09:38.889 --> 00:09:42.679
that exactly this thing is needed and the intellectual curiosity to

151
00:09:42.679 --> 00:09:46.197
build it. So we've always been outside-the-box thinkers.

152
00:09:46.472 --> 00:09:50.073
The interesting problems no one else is touching, those are typically

153
00:09:50.816 --> 00:09:54.152
our projects. When do we spin it out?

154
00:09:54.459 --> 00:09:58.195
Typically when something outgrows us. So Safe and CoW were very

155
00:09:58.195 --> 00:10:00.266
much started as internal needs,

156
00:10:01.997 --> 00:10:05.774
but once they were ecosystem infrastructure with their own

157
00:10:05.806 --> 00:10:08.692
gravity and kind of they needed an independence,

158
00:10:09.762 --> 00:10:13.313
that— made them stronger. So non-extraction very much

159
00:10:13.313 --> 00:10:16.547
applies internally too. So we'd

160
00:10:17.013 --> 00:10:20.667
rather build when we think

161
00:10:20.732 --> 00:10:23.903
there's a unique solution that only we can

162
00:10:24.756 --> 00:10:27.106
build or that we can uniquely build.

163
00:10:29.000 --> 00:10:32.656
If it's something else, we can also support when others are

164
00:10:32.673 --> 00:10:36.396
closer to the problem. So capital and infrastructure. through

165
00:10:36.765 --> 00:10:40.537
Gnosis DAO, kind of, that's not a problem. And kind of you

166
00:10:40.537 --> 00:10:43.923
just post a Gnosis improvement proposal to

167
00:10:44.404 --> 00:10:47.726
the DAO forum and often they do actually get funded.

168
00:10:48.946 --> 00:10:52.396
And when do we just stay out of it? Often when it's

169
00:10:52.396 --> 00:10:55.847
commodity work, to be honest. So if it will get built

170
00:10:55.847 --> 00:10:59.281
anyway and it needs neither our conviction

171
00:10:59.313 --> 00:11:02.202
nor our curiosity, it—

172
00:11:03.439 --> 00:11:07.216
Safe, CoW Protocol, and Gnosis Pay look like separate

173
00:11:07.248 --> 00:11:10.501
products from the outside. What strategic system connects

174
00:11:10.533 --> 00:11:14.058
self-custody, decentralized trading, and crypto payments?

175
00:11:14.442 --> 00:11:17.839
Yeah, um, so in my eyes, it needs to be genuinely useful.

176
00:11:18.159 --> 00:11:21.812
So it should solve a real problem, um, people

177
00:11:21.812 --> 00:11:25.289
return to. It shouldn't be just a token with a user interface, right?

178
00:11:25.673 --> 00:11:29.086
Then it needs to be audited exhaustively. We already talked about the scams,

179
00:11:29.439 --> 00:11:32.266
so every audit it can go through and then some.

180
00:11:33.205 --> 00:11:36.946
And then you let time test it. So years

181
00:11:36.946 --> 00:11:40.314
in production under real adversarial pressure,

182
00:11:40.734 --> 00:11:42.495
that's typically

183
00:11:44.693 --> 00:11:47.360
what gets you to a state

184
00:11:48.573 --> 00:11:52.324
where something becomes infrastructure

185
00:11:53.181 --> 00:11:57.030
that you can build on. And the fourth thing

186
00:11:57.159 --> 00:12:00.731
that people often neglect

187
00:12:01.069 --> 00:12:04.596
is minimal attack surface by design.

188
00:12:05.047 --> 00:12:08.712
So if you have a large surface area that

189
00:12:09.068 --> 00:12:12.837
hackers can hack into, it's disqualifying.

190
00:12:13.274 --> 00:12:16.977
It's why bridges are the perennial hacking target, right? Kind of you

191
00:12:16.993 --> 00:12:19.534
have maximum complexity, you have the maximum honeypot.

192
00:12:21.090 --> 00:12:24.746
So infrastructure should be boring and small. And hard to get wrong.

193
00:12:25.499 --> 00:12:29.296
Where is the crypto market still confusing self-custody with

194
00:12:29.360 --> 00:12:33.046
actual usability? Yeah, they're all expressions of the same core

195
00:12:33.046 --> 00:12:35.962
beliefs, right? So kind of the agency, no lock-in,

196
00:12:36.395 --> 00:12:40.016
non-extractive design, and they're just applied to different

197
00:12:40.016 --> 00:12:43.782
moments in the life of your money. So together they kind

198
00:12:43.782 --> 00:12:47.483
of cover the full loop. You hold money, you trade money, you

199
00:12:47.483 --> 00:12:51.283
spend money. Safe secures your assets. CoW lets you exchange

200
00:12:51.315 --> 00:12:55.009
them without being front-run or milked, and Gnosis

201
00:12:55.009 --> 00:12:58.654
Pay lets you spend them in the real world. So all

202
00:12:58.766 --> 00:13:02.572
without ever handing your money to someone else. So

203
00:13:02.572 --> 00:13:06.410
it's the same pattern in each. You take a function that required

204
00:13:06.410 --> 00:13:10.055
a trusted intermediary and you rebuild it so that

205
00:13:10.264 --> 00:13:12.592
the protection comes from the system and not from the

206
00:13:12.592 --> 00:13:16.382
custodian. So that's kind of

207
00:13:16.751 --> 00:13:20.122
what in my mind binds them together despite the fact that kind of they

208
00:13:20.604 --> 00:13:24.182
cover different parts of the cycle. To

209
00:13:24.198 --> 00:13:27.568
me, they're very much a triptych. They're not a random assortment of

210
00:13:27.680 --> 00:13:31.227
projects. What metric would prove to you that

211
00:13:31.291 --> 00:13:34.821
Gnosis Pay, Safe, or CoW Protocol has crossed from

212
00:13:34.821 --> 00:13:38.127
crypto-native adoption into real financial

213
00:13:38.287 --> 00:13:42.122
service infrastructure? Oh yeah, absolutely. When people

214
00:13:42.122 --> 00:13:45.396
use it without understanding how or why it works. So

215
00:13:45.396 --> 00:13:49.052
nobody knows how TCP/IP works and everyone

216
00:13:49.325 --> 00:13:53.078
happily browses the internet. And to me that's very

217
00:13:53.126 --> 00:13:56.878
much the bar. So the measurable

218
00:13:56.878 --> 00:14:00.038
version of this is the share of users who couldn't tell you they're using a

219
00:14:00.086 --> 00:14:03.710
blockchain. They tapped a card, they got paid, they swapped currencies.

220
00:14:04.255 --> 00:14:06.982
And when that share dominates, we've crossed over.

221
00:14:08.086 --> 00:14:10.574
Guys, we will be back after a short ad break.

222
00:14:12.125 --> 00:14:15.923
Answer the question, can Gnosis make decentralized finance

223
00:14:16.231 --> 00:14:19.126
usable enough for mainstream adoption without

224
00:14:19.401 --> 00:14:23.099
centralizing the trust layer that Ethereum was

225
00:14:23.213 --> 00:14:24.154
designed to remove?

226
00:14:29.783 --> 00:14:33.337
Hey guys, welcome back to the ad break. Let's get right back

227
00:14:33.418 --> 00:14:36.728
into the interview of Friederike, co-founder of Gnosis,

228
00:14:37.166 --> 00:14:40.899
where Do banks, fintech startups in Europe,

229
00:14:40.979 --> 00:14:44.170
and regulators most underestimate crypto

230
00:14:44.347 --> 00:14:47.890
payments? I don't think they misunderstand it anymore.

231
00:14:48.035 --> 00:14:51.851
That's exactly why they're getting into it, right? So Revolut is

232
00:14:51.883 --> 00:14:55.460
now the largest crypto trading venue in Europe. Robinhood

233
00:14:55.796 --> 00:14:59.581
launched its own chain. The technology argument to me is over.

234
00:14:59.757 --> 00:15:03.590
So kind of the problem to me is what they

235
00:15:03.670 --> 00:15:07.004
bring with them and that's the extractive business models.

236
00:15:07.436 --> 00:15:10.866
They port over the lock-in, the spreads, the walled gardens and

237
00:15:10.882 --> 00:15:14.632
blockchain becomes just a new backend for Wall

238
00:15:14.632 --> 00:15:18.125
Street. So if that's adoption of the rails

239
00:15:18.253 --> 00:15:22.067
without adoption of the point, to me crypto very much

240
00:15:22.164 --> 00:15:25.994
has failed, right? You don't want cheaper plumbing

241
00:15:26.090 --> 00:15:28.958
for incumbents, you want more power for the users.

242
00:15:29.936 --> 00:15:33.718
What has to become invisible before Gnosis Pay or

243
00:15:33.718 --> 00:15:37.326
any other crypto payment system can compete with the

244
00:15:37.326 --> 00:15:40.903
existing payment rails? It already competes, just

245
00:15:41.309 --> 00:15:44.753
not in Europe yet. The reason is

246
00:15:44.945 --> 00:15:48.721
that you need the pain to be acute and

247
00:15:48.785 --> 00:15:52.625
that then kind of invisibility has already happened. People aren't

248
00:15:52.657 --> 00:15:56.335
using crypto, and I'm using inverted commas here, they're sending money

249
00:15:56.432 --> 00:15:59.469
home cheaper, right? So look for instance at LATAM.

250
00:16:01.197 --> 00:16:02.070
You have

251
00:16:03.530 --> 00:16:06.643
$174 billion

252
00:16:07.302 --> 00:16:11.062
in remittances to LATAM in 2025. And

253
00:16:11.352 --> 00:16:13.558
stablecoins here are the main growth driver.

254
00:16:15.142 --> 00:16:18.877
Stablecoins were 40% of all crypto purchases in LATAM

255
00:16:18.926 --> 00:16:22.419
in 2025 and over 70% in

256
00:16:22.895 --> 00:16:25.737
Argentina. So kind of, if you look at these stats,

257
00:16:28.148 --> 00:16:31.660
Not that crypto can't compete, it's

258
00:16:31.901 --> 00:16:34.964
that we are

259
00:16:35.574 --> 00:16:39.295
already on a technically very high level in Europe.

260
00:16:39.535 --> 00:16:42.695
So in Europe, bar is super high because SEPA is

261
00:16:43.513 --> 00:16:47.282
good, right? Kind of like it's free and it's instant. So what

262
00:16:47.282 --> 00:16:51.083
still has to disappear here? Probably the

263
00:16:51.131 --> 00:16:54.884
on/off-ramps, gas and anything else that

264
00:16:54.916 --> 00:16:58.735
feels like crypto rather than money. And that's exactly

265
00:16:58.767 --> 00:17:02.189
what Gnosis Pay does. So kind of you tap a card, a Visa card,

266
00:17:02.687 --> 00:17:06.398
and the self-custody underneath is nobody's homework. It just

267
00:17:06.800 --> 00:17:10.626
works. Where does account abstraction

268
00:17:10.820 --> 00:17:14.454
change user experience of self-custody and where is the market

269
00:17:14.454 --> 00:17:15.536
still overselling it?

270
00:17:17.905 --> 00:17:21.266
It's a building block, right? So where it genuinely

271
00:17:21.298 --> 00:17:24.188
changes self-custody is it kills the seed phrase.

272
00:17:25.092 --> 00:17:28.549
So with passkeys and social recovery and hardware you already own,

273
00:17:29.318 --> 00:17:32.923
losing your phone stops meaning losing your money. It also makes

274
00:17:32.923 --> 00:17:36.592
gas disappear. So sponsored transactions pay fees in whatever you

275
00:17:36.592 --> 00:17:40.406
hold. One less alien concept, i.e., that you actually have to pay

276
00:17:40.870 --> 00:17:44.716
to move money. And it enables the policy engine. So kind of you

277
00:17:44.716 --> 00:17:48.465
can have spending limits, delays, allowlists, co-signing, the

278
00:17:48.465 --> 00:17:51.797
bank-style protections that we talked about finally living

279
00:17:52.214 --> 00:17:56.034
in your own account. This is a huge one and Safe has been proving

280
00:17:56.082 --> 00:17:59.905
it for years. Where we're overselling it, it doesn't, it very much

281
00:17:59.937 --> 00:18:03.759
doesn't stop scams, right? If you're socially engineered

282
00:18:03.791 --> 00:18:07.614
into approving a transaction, account abstraction executes it for you

283
00:18:07.646 --> 00:18:11.067
beautifully. The recourse problem is a policy

284
00:18:11.099 --> 00:18:14.553
and user experience problem, not a signature scheme.

285
00:18:15.340 --> 00:18:19.098
It's plumbing, right? It's not a product. So we have

286
00:18:19.226 --> 00:18:22.037
account abstraction doesn't mean good user experience and

287
00:18:23.307 --> 00:18:27.036
And any more than kind of any other technical feature

288
00:18:27.949 --> 00:18:31.634
means good user experience. Kind of you can have the most beautiful database in the

289
00:18:31.634 --> 00:18:35.335
world, doesn't necessarily translate into a fantastic product, right?

290
00:18:36.825 --> 00:18:40.045
What is the hardest constraint in making Gnosis Pay useful?

291
00:18:40.189 --> 00:18:44.034
Regulation, UX, liquidity, merchant acceptance, or

292
00:18:44.034 --> 00:18:47.142
trust? None of these actually.

293
00:18:47.238 --> 00:18:50.634
It's local stablecoins and on-ramps. So kind of

294
00:18:51.179 --> 00:18:55.009
if you look at the things you just listed, They're largely solved, right? So

295
00:18:55.009 --> 00:18:58.616
merchant acceptance comes free

296
00:18:58.616 --> 00:19:02.367
with Visa. User experience is a tap, kind of exactly

297
00:19:02.415 --> 00:19:05.172
the same format that then with all your other cards.

298
00:19:05.846 --> 00:19:09.501
Regulation is handled at the zone level. Trust is earned

299
00:19:10.318 --> 00:19:14.069
by shipping. But you can't spend money you

300
00:19:14.181 --> 00:19:17.820
can't get in, denominated in a currency you don't live in,

301
00:19:17.868 --> 00:19:21.523
right? Most of the world's stablecoin liquidity is very much in US dollars.

302
00:19:21.635 --> 00:19:24.777
People earn and budget in euros and reais and pesos.

303
00:19:25.387 --> 00:19:29.223
Without deep local currency stables, every purchase hides

304
00:19:29.415 --> 00:19:32.898
an FX leg. And that is a

305
00:19:33.251 --> 00:19:37.087
huge downside. I am 100% convinced that

306
00:19:37.344 --> 00:19:41.019
over the next year or 2, we will see a huge

307
00:19:41.693 --> 00:19:44.823
resurgence in local stablecoins and see the

308
00:19:44.823 --> 00:19:48.563
dollar predominance shrink also in

309
00:19:48.595 --> 00:19:50.649
the cryptosphere. But we're not there yet.

310
00:19:52.474 --> 00:19:56.283
Gnosis Chain is deliberately onboarding non-US dollar stablecoins.

311
00:19:57.280 --> 00:20:01.108
The payment vision just works if the money on the rails

312
00:20:01.205 --> 00:20:05.031
is the money that people actually want to use.

313
00:20:06.930 --> 00:20:10.617
When you compare Europe with the US, where does Europe have a real

314
00:20:10.649 --> 00:20:14.417
advantage in decentralized financial instruments? First, I

315
00:20:14.433 --> 00:20:18.046
would say regulatory clarity, at least to a degree. MiCA isn't

316
00:20:18.046 --> 00:20:21.776
perfect, but it's one rulebook that passports

317
00:20:21.824 --> 00:20:25.490
across 27 countries. And the US just

318
00:20:25.490 --> 00:20:29.266
spent years regulating by enforcement. So

319
00:20:29.282 --> 00:20:33.043
you can build compliant crypto payments products in Europe and

320
00:20:33.059 --> 00:20:36.488
know the rules won't flip with the next election. That's a

321
00:20:36.536 --> 00:20:40.210
huge benefit. We also

322
00:20:40.243 --> 00:20:44.065
have the best fiat rails in the world to plug into. SEPA

323
00:20:44.065 --> 00:20:47.740
Instant and open banking make the on/off-ramp

324
00:20:47.740 --> 00:20:51.190
problem, that's our hardest constraint, dramatically

325
00:20:51.270 --> 00:20:54.946
easier here. Gnosis Pay exists in its current form only

326
00:20:55.058 --> 00:20:58.878
because European plumbing allows it. So kind of if you, it has an

327
00:20:58.974 --> 00:21:02.810
integration with Monerium. So kind of every

328
00:21:03.066 --> 00:21:05.650
wallet automatically gets a SEPA,

329
00:21:06.276 --> 00:21:09.983
an IBAN that you can just send a SEPA transfer

330
00:21:09.983 --> 00:21:13.755
to. So if you want to top up your Gnosis Pay card, do an

331
00:21:13.755 --> 00:21:17.415
instant SEPA transfer and it shows up in your wallet a couple of seconds

332
00:21:17.447 --> 00:21:20.947
later. It's beautiful, really. Where does European

333
00:21:21.284 --> 00:21:24.992
regulatory seriousness become a strength and where does it

334
00:21:24.992 --> 00:21:28.700
become execution drag? It's typically the number that

335
00:21:28.700 --> 00:21:32.489
starts in DE whatever, whatever, kind of FR if you're in

336
00:21:32.537 --> 00:21:35.924
France and BE if you're in Belgium. So that number, you

337
00:21:36.310 --> 00:21:39.472
have one associated with your wallet and kind of if you are on your

338
00:21:40.507 --> 00:21:43.964
local bank interface, you send euros to that address,

339
00:21:44.368 --> 00:21:48.184
to that bank account

340
00:21:48.184 --> 00:21:51.646
number, and they show up in your wallet seconds later.

341
00:21:51.889 --> 00:21:55.514
It's beautiful. Okay, then kind of what

342
00:21:55.595 --> 00:21:58.767
other chances, what other advantages do we have in Europe?

343
00:21:59.350 --> 00:22:02.864
So I think the euro gives us a non-US dollar stablecoin

344
00:22:02.897 --> 00:22:06.509
opportunity just because it is a relatively stable

345
00:22:08.342 --> 00:22:11.954
currency and much of the world doesn't really want a dollarized

346
00:22:11.954 --> 00:22:15.747
account anymore. And then we also have the

347
00:22:15.747 --> 00:22:19.491
values alignment. So Europe's instincts as to data

348
00:22:19.491 --> 00:22:23.010
protection and distrust of platform monopolies and consumer protection,

349
00:22:23.604 --> 00:22:27.204
they often map directly onto self-custody and non-extractive

350
00:22:27.204 --> 00:22:30.723
design. It's just that regulators

351
00:22:30.996 --> 00:22:34.532
and people in power don't always understand this

352
00:22:34.532 --> 00:22:38.374
upfront. Where does the American hypergrowth model fail when

353
00:22:38.374 --> 00:22:41.381
applied to Ethereum infrastructure and decentralized finance?

354
00:22:42.154 --> 00:22:46.002
Interesting question. So if you look at hypergrowth

355
00:22:46.340 --> 00:22:50.108
and how it works, it works by capturing the users first and

356
00:22:50.221 --> 00:22:53.798
then it milks them, right? So you subsidize the acquisition, you

357
00:22:53.863 --> 00:22:57.506
build switching costs, and then you extract later. And this whole

358
00:22:57.506 --> 00:23:00.876
model depends on the exit door being expensive.

359
00:23:01.550 --> 00:23:05.163
And open rails very much break that model. So when a

360
00:23:05.227 --> 00:23:08.342
user holds their own assets and leaving costs you nothing,

361
00:23:09.097 --> 00:23:12.501
then the milking phase never arrives. So you can buy

362
00:23:12.694 --> 00:23:16.515
users, but you can't keep them hostages. Where does the

363
00:23:16.644 --> 00:23:20.465
European capital efficiency model become discipline, and where does

364
00:23:20.577 --> 00:23:23.275
it become fear disguised as prudence?

365
00:23:25.674 --> 00:23:29.516
The discipline, I think it's not having that VC

366
00:23:29.516 --> 00:23:32.628
culture, right? Kind of you are building for the revenue, you're not building for the

367
00:23:32.628 --> 00:23:36.129
next round. So European frugality forces

368
00:23:36.567 --> 00:23:40.247
real business models early, which happens to match how

369
00:23:40.280 --> 00:23:43.679
infrastructure is actually won slowly by not dying.

370
00:23:45.436 --> 00:23:49.143
It becomes fear when prudence means only

371
00:23:49.337 --> 00:23:52.961
funding what's already proven, right? Kind of incremental bets,

372
00:23:53.042 --> 00:23:56.716
consensus ideas, waiting for the US to validate a category

373
00:23:57.149 --> 00:24:00.791
before touching it. That's not risk management, that's

374
00:24:01.064 --> 00:24:04.754
outsourcing conviction to some extent, right? What's the tell?

375
00:24:06.037 --> 00:24:09.711
Discipline says no to bad economics and fear says no to ambition. So

376
00:24:10.064 --> 00:24:13.594
Europe in principle doesn't lack capital, but kind of if you look at where

377
00:24:13.594 --> 00:24:17.156
VC investments are still by and large made, It's the US.

378
00:24:17.765 --> 00:24:21.535
So we lack the willingness to write an uncomfortable

379
00:24:21.535 --> 00:24:25.033
check. And that's the irony. So kind of the biggest infrastructure prizes

380
00:24:25.466 --> 00:24:29.204
go to whoever endures longest. And endurance is

381
00:24:29.541 --> 00:24:33.295
the one thing capital efficiency actually trains you for. Under

382
00:24:33.311 --> 00:24:37.017
what conditions would Gnosis choose speed over

383
00:24:37.017 --> 00:24:40.595
decentralization? Oh, decentralization isn't a value in

384
00:24:40.643 --> 00:24:44.413
itself, right? So kind of it can foster resilience, but kind of if

385
00:24:44.702 --> 00:24:48.213
you only look at decentralization, Decentralization, that's very much a vanity

386
00:24:48.823 --> 00:24:52.221
metric. It should be a means and there are real trade-offs to

387
00:24:52.333 --> 00:24:56.100
being decentralized on every axis. What

388
00:24:56.100 --> 00:24:59.723
we actually care about is agency, being able to exit and neutrality.

389
00:25:00.445 --> 00:25:04.084
So the Ethereum Economic Zone, which is something that we're building kind of with

390
00:25:04.100 --> 00:25:06.873
funding from the Ethereum Foundation, makes this

391
00:25:07.626 --> 00:25:11.169
trade-off very concrete. So kind of Gnosis Chain is becoming a zone in the

392
00:25:11.169 --> 00:25:14.667
Ethereum Economic Zone. But there's no way to

393
00:25:14.699 --> 00:25:18.360
compose synchronously with Ethereum, meaning to access everything

394
00:25:18.472 --> 00:25:21.507
that is on Ethereum as if you were on the network itself

395
00:25:22.470 --> 00:25:26.196
and build fast blocks at the same time. It's simply physics. It's

396
00:25:26.485 --> 00:25:30.242
not ideology. So we chose speed and

397
00:25:30.354 --> 00:25:33.822
waiting for the next Ethereum block for full economic

398
00:25:33.822 --> 00:25:37.596
security. Fast blocks you need for

399
00:25:37.596 --> 00:25:40.919
payment experience. You can't wait for 12 or 24 seconds.

400
00:25:42.174 --> 00:25:45.620
for kind of executing a payment when you're standing at

401
00:25:46.181 --> 00:25:49.663
the point of sale terminal at

402
00:25:49.759 --> 00:25:53.545
Aldi, right? So you need the fast blocks for the

403
00:25:53.545 --> 00:25:57.331
payment experience. You need the Ethereum ultimately for

404
00:25:57.331 --> 00:26:01.085
the settlement guarantees. So you choose speed when the

405
00:26:01.085 --> 00:26:04.903
user feels it and you keep decentralization

406
00:26:05.577 --> 00:26:09.277
when the security model And under

407
00:26:09.389 --> 00:26:13.006
what conditions would you take external venture

408
00:26:13.006 --> 00:26:16.189
capital? We're currently not capital constrained.

409
00:26:18.069 --> 00:26:21.001
Okay. So we take on external capital

410
00:26:22.837 --> 00:26:26.529
kind of when it's strategic. The Gnosis DAO treasury is

411
00:26:26.529 --> 00:26:28.993
still well in excess of

412
00:26:29.154 --> 00:26:32.118
$100 million.

413
00:26:33.214 --> 00:26:36.886
So we're, we're good. We take

414
00:26:37.191 --> 00:26:39.680
capital for its strategic value. And

415
00:26:40.162 --> 00:26:43.582
then it doesn't matter whether,

416
00:26:44.176 --> 00:26:47.789
what kind of party it's from. We would even take it from VCs.

417
00:26:48.415 --> 00:26:52.108
Often the business incentives are not aligned for

418
00:26:52.124 --> 00:26:55.656
VCs. So kind of like if you look at it, the business model for

419
00:26:55.656 --> 00:26:58.996
VC is to buy a token and then later to sell it at an upside,

420
00:26:59.590 --> 00:27:02.691
right? That's essentially the business model of a VC.

421
00:27:03.224 --> 00:27:06.505
It's not long-term value creation. So often partnering with

422
00:27:06.941 --> 00:27:10.525
other partners is more

423
00:27:10.573 --> 00:27:13.735
conducive. It's just that often you get

424
00:27:15.252 --> 00:27:18.171
money with fewer questions asked from VCs.

425
00:27:18.252 --> 00:27:22.006
Getting to our last official question of the

426
00:27:22.006 --> 00:27:25.308
interview, I was wondering what prediction about crypto payments,

427
00:27:25.325 --> 00:27:28.996
self-custody, Decentralized trading or Ethereum

428
00:27:29.125 --> 00:27:32.817
infrastructure should we be able to judge as right or wrong

429
00:27:33.010 --> 00:27:35.858
within 3 years? 2029, that is.

430
00:27:38.490 --> 00:27:42.106
So I would assume that self-custodial spending goes mainstream in Europe.

431
00:27:42.187 --> 00:27:45.715
So kind of, and the metric you look at is how many millions of Europeans

432
00:27:45.828 --> 00:27:49.590
pay daily from smart accounts, card or phone, without even knowing

433
00:27:49.638 --> 00:27:53.468
what a blockchain is. That's your metric right there.

434
00:27:54.212 --> 00:27:57.398
Second prediction that is definitely testable is

435
00:27:57.997 --> 00:28:01.798
non-US dollar stablecoins stop being a rounding error.

436
00:28:01.895 --> 00:28:05.484
So currently 99% of stablecoin volume on-chain is

437
00:28:05.517 --> 00:28:08.975
US dollars. And we will see a

438
00:28:10.472 --> 00:28:14.306
big surge in euro and other local currency stables.

439
00:28:16.283 --> 00:28:17.832
That's my second prediction.

440
00:28:19.974 --> 00:28:21.888
And my third one,

441
00:28:23.447 --> 00:28:27.140
maybe definitely the most controversial I think, is

442
00:28:27.237 --> 00:28:31.030
corporate chains will fail the exit test. So kind

443
00:28:31.030 --> 00:28:34.839
of if you look at fintech-owned chains, so Robinhood and

444
00:28:34.903 --> 00:28:38.177
others, they will grow, but they

445
00:28:38.612 --> 00:28:41.788
will not produce lasting user ownership and no open

446
00:28:41.853 --> 00:28:45.570
composability. So kind of, if you look at this in a

447
00:28:45.570 --> 00:28:49.314
couple of years, in 2029, ask yourself one question:

448
00:28:49.379 --> 00:28:52.951
can users leave with their assets at no cost? And

449
00:28:53.097 --> 00:28:56.642
if yes, then kind of you can tell me I've been wrong

450
00:28:56.903 --> 00:29:00.508
about this. Normally we end our

451
00:29:00.508 --> 00:29:04.354
interview with 2 questions, but you already answered the first one,

452
00:29:04.548 --> 00:29:06.779
if you would be open to talk to new investors.

453
00:29:08.595 --> 00:29:11.936
Are you currently looking for talented people? Are you hiring?

454
00:29:12.967 --> 00:29:16.524
Yeah, absolutely. So we always have open positions

455
00:29:17.373 --> 00:29:21.219
and it's typically people who are smart, who think

456
00:29:21.219 --> 00:29:24.809
outside of the box, who want to move the needle. We're always

457
00:29:24.841 --> 00:29:28.511
interested. Ulrike, thank you very much. It was a pleasure

458
00:29:28.847 --> 00:29:32.180
having you as a guest. Thank you so much for having me. It was, it

459
00:29:32.196 --> 00:29:35.946
was, the pleasure was all mine. If a founder in Germany, Austria, or Switzerland

460
00:29:36.042 --> 00:29:39.744
wants to build financial infrastructure instead of chasing the

461
00:29:39.744 --> 00:29:43.429
next crypto cycle? What decision rule should they adopt before they

462
00:29:43.429 --> 00:29:47.147
raise capital, hire a team, or choose their first

463
00:29:47.259 --> 00:29:50.976
market? This was Joe Menninger for

464
00:29:50.976 --> 00:29:54.710
Startuprad.io. Really sorry if not all the

465
00:29:54.790 --> 00:29:58.107
audio matched my questions to Friederike.

466
00:29:58.636 --> 00:30:02.065
I did have an issue with my video and audio recording,

467
00:30:02.418 --> 00:30:05.433
so I had to re-record all the questions. Thanks, guys.