WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.276 --> 00:00:03.386
Europe has a scale-up fund with a €5 billion

2
00:00:04.045 --> 00:00:07.785
target. The European Commission has put in €1

3
00:00:07.817 --> 00:00:11.155
billion, and that is the only commitment we could find

4
00:00:11.188 --> 00:00:14.462
disclosed by name. Europe has a new company for

5
00:00:14.462 --> 00:00:17.977
startups. It is still a proposal, and the European Parliament

6
00:00:18.475 --> 00:00:22.039
has not yet voted on it. Europe has a new

7
00:00:22.167 --> 00:00:25.714
rulebook for public buyers. The target for finishing the

8
00:00:25.714 --> 00:00:27.769
negotiations is end

9
00:00:31.629 --> 00:00:35.447
Europe is adding growth capital faster than it is removing

10
00:00:35.560 --> 00:00:38.173
the barriers to scaling. The question for

11
00:00:38.318 --> 00:00:41.911
2031 is whether its best companies

12
00:00:42.412 --> 00:00:46.054
can grow globally without having to move their strategic

13
00:00:46.054 --> 00:00:47.550
center out of Europe.

14
00:00:58.135 --> 00:01:01.818
This is Startuprad.io, your startup podcast and YouTube

15
00:01:01.882 --> 00:01:05.377
channel on startups and venture capital in Europe with focus on

16
00:01:05.409 --> 00:01:09.192
Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. Hello and welcome everybody, my name

17
00:01:09.192 --> 00:01:12.926
is Joe. I am coming to you from Frankfurt am Main, Germany, and

18
00:01:13.167 --> 00:01:16.869
this is part number 8 of our series, The European

19
00:01:16.869 --> 00:01:20.572
Scale-Up Question or The European Scale-Up Gap. For

20
00:01:20.716 --> 00:01:24.085
7 episodes, we diagnosed the problem Today we

21
00:01:24.230 --> 00:01:27.902
ask what would actually have to change between, say,

22
00:01:28.030 --> 00:01:31.798
2027— we're very close to it— and 2031 for

23
00:01:31.798 --> 00:01:34.829
Europe to produce more globally scaled technology companies.

24
00:01:35.447 --> 00:01:37.839
And we write down how we will check.

25
00:01:39.662 --> 00:01:43.107
It's 2 years after the Draghi report. The Joint European

26
00:01:43.107 --> 00:01:46.923
Disruptive Initiative tracked the follow-through. According to

27
00:01:46.987 --> 00:01:50.753
its Draghi Tracker, about a quarter the recommendations

28
00:01:51.106 --> 00:01:54.510
have been implemented. Europe does measure its startup

29
00:01:54.558 --> 00:01:57.850
conditions. The European Commission publishes a Startup and

30
00:01:57.850 --> 00:02:01.141
Scale-Up Scoreboard with 36

31
00:02:01.221 --> 00:02:04.914
indicators comparing member states. What nobody

32
00:02:04.914 --> 00:02:08.093
tracks in public is the outcome for the same companies

33
00:02:08.591 --> 00:02:12.268
over time— which ones scaled, which ones moved,

34
00:02:12.621 --> 00:02:15.511
and which ones failed. This is the gap.

35
00:02:16.217 --> 00:02:19.766
This episode tries to fill. So today I

36
00:02:19.766 --> 00:02:23.187
separate 3 things: policy announcement— what

37
00:02:23.219 --> 00:02:25.933
governments and institutions say they will do—

38
00:02:26.752 --> 00:02:30.268
infrastructure changes— what actually alters the

39
00:02:30.268 --> 00:02:33.223
conditions under which companies scale—

40
00:02:33.881 --> 00:02:37.719
and observable outcomes— what founders, investors, and

41
00:02:37.751 --> 00:02:41.429
customers then do differently. Most of the

42
00:02:41.429 --> 00:02:45.268
debate is about the first This episode is more about the

43
00:02:45.462 --> 00:02:48.927
third. So here's my thesis in one breath:

44
00:02:50.644 --> 00:02:54.430
Europe is adding growth capital faster than it's removing

45
00:02:54.527 --> 00:02:57.842
some of the barriers to scale. This

46
00:02:57.842 --> 00:03:01.092
creates a risk— companies may still need to

47
00:03:01.092 --> 00:03:04.645
relocate to grow. Our scorecard will

48
00:03:04.693 --> 00:03:07.941
test whether they can scale globally

49
00:03:08.568 --> 00:03:12.141
while keeping their strategic center in Europe, and it will

50
00:03:12.223 --> 00:03:15.871
reward the cases that prove us wrong. I

51
00:03:15.984 --> 00:03:19.497
call the timing mismatch the sequencing gap. A new

52
00:03:19.610 --> 00:03:23.107
program is an input. A company scaling differently

53
00:03:23.541 --> 00:03:27.038
is an outcome. This episode rates Europe on outcomes.

54
00:03:28.097 --> 00:03:31.900
Where we are in the argument: Part 1 defines the scale-up gap

55
00:03:32.846 --> 00:03:35.943
in our overall series. I mean, Part 2 called

56
00:03:35.975 --> 00:03:39.778
fragmentation a hidden growth tax. Part 3 of our

57
00:03:40.131 --> 00:03:43.290
scale-up series showed a capital architecture

58
00:03:43.514 --> 00:03:46.895
breaks between the rounds. Part 4

59
00:03:47.600 --> 00:03:51.126
was demand that does not turn into deployment.

60
00:03:51.927 --> 00:03:55.116
Part 5 was talent that does not

61
00:03:55.116 --> 00:03:58.625
recycle. Part 6 introduced capital

62
00:03:58.641 --> 00:04:01.894
gravity, and Part 7 showed that Europe's

63
00:04:01.894 --> 00:04:05.628
strongest hubs do not add up to one market.

64
00:04:06.589 --> 00:04:09.796
In Parts 6 and 7, we We put a forecast on record.

65
00:04:10.679 --> 00:04:14.529
The EU Inc. will not apply before January 1st,

66
00:04:15.010 --> 00:04:18.860
2028, at 75% confidence. That

67
00:04:18.860 --> 00:04:22.710
forecast stays still on record and we'll score it on

68
00:04:22.710 --> 00:04:26.399
that date. Well, maybe a few days later because,

69
00:04:26.640 --> 00:04:30.426
you know, New Year's. Anyway, today I add a second

70
00:04:30.715 --> 00:04:33.811
stricter one. Defining scale

71
00:04:33.923 --> 00:04:37.725
infrastructure. First, a definition, because we will use

72
00:04:37.758 --> 00:04:41.590
this from now on. Scale infrastructure

73
00:04:42.169 --> 00:04:45.625
is the set of financial, commercial, institutional,

74
00:04:46.011 --> 00:04:49.404
and human systems that lets a company grow from

75
00:04:49.549 --> 00:04:53.075
product-market fit into global leader without rebuilding

76
00:04:53.429 --> 00:04:56.134
its operating environment every time it grows.

77
00:04:57.148 --> 00:05:00.969
Startup Radio's way to measure it is the the

78
00:05:00.969 --> 00:05:04.781
Scale Infrastructure Scorecard. It has

79
00:05:05.135 --> 00:05:08.802
5 tests, and each test asks about companies'

80
00:05:08.834 --> 00:05:11.550
behavior, not government announcements.

81
00:05:13.013 --> 00:05:16.163
Number 1, capital. Can a company raise its

82
00:05:16.468 --> 00:05:20.219
next growth round without having to

83
00:05:20.251 --> 00:05:23.875
move its parent company? The market. Can they

84
00:05:23.939 --> 00:05:27.386
expand into another European country

85
00:05:27.796 --> 00:05:30.913
as a domestic decision. Demand—

86
00:05:31.855 --> 00:05:35.656
can it win repeat European customers,

87
00:05:36.241 --> 00:05:39.323
not just pilots? People—

88
00:05:40.083 --> 00:05:43.557
do its operators come back as founders and

89
00:05:43.621 --> 00:05:47.233
angels? Retention— as it grows,

90
00:05:48.377 --> 00:05:52.149
do its parent company, its leadership, and its listing

91
00:05:52.439 --> 00:05:56.210
stay in Europe? And here is how we keep

92
00:05:56.210 --> 00:05:59.925
it honest. We do not pick like the best 50

93
00:05:59.974 --> 00:06:02.787
companies in 2031. That would,

94
00:06:04.427 --> 00:06:07.463
uh, kind of select the answer. We fix the group now.

95
00:06:08.172 --> 00:06:11.789
Our cohort is every company headquartered in Europe that

96
00:06:11.789 --> 00:06:15.036
announced funding of €100 million or more

97
00:06:15.567 --> 00:06:19.360
in calendar year 2026. We freeze that list

98
00:06:19.783 --> 00:06:23.463
at the end of January 2027. And publish it. Every

99
00:06:23.495 --> 00:06:27.063
company stays in the cohort, including the ones that

100
00:06:27.127 --> 00:06:30.953
fail, get acquired, or relocate. Each year

101
00:06:31.147 --> 00:06:34.982
we score every company on the 5 tests and we

102
00:06:35.046 --> 00:06:38.704
publish results, including the cases that contradict

103
00:06:38.704 --> 00:06:42.320
us. Before I make my case,

104
00:06:42.757 --> 00:06:46.399
the strongest opposing argument, it goes something like this:

105
00:06:46.949 --> 00:06:50.780
capital buys time. Europe's reforms are slow, so the

106
00:06:50.780 --> 00:06:54.201
best thing a growth fund can do is keep good companies

107
00:06:54.297 --> 00:06:56.963
funded until the rules catch up.

108
00:06:57.911 --> 00:07:01.395
And international investors are not a threat. A strategic

109
00:07:01.395 --> 00:07:05.201
investor can bring customers and supply chain. An American

110
00:07:05.298 --> 00:07:09.056
fund can bring expertise and access to the largest market in the world.

111
00:07:09.810 --> 00:07:13.584
A company can take that money, list in New York, hire

112
00:07:13.584 --> 00:07:16.764
commercial team in California, and still be a European

113
00:07:16.780 --> 00:07:20.378
company in every way that matters— research,

114
00:07:20.651 --> 00:07:24.314
engineering, leadership, tax. I think that argument

115
00:07:24.410 --> 00:07:27.977
is largely right, and I want to say so clearly.

116
00:07:28.989 --> 00:07:31.945
Foreign capital can help European companies

117
00:07:32.459 --> 00:07:36.041
become global leaders. So the risk I'm

118
00:07:36.057 --> 00:07:39.800
casting is narrower. The failure is not

119
00:07:39.848 --> 00:07:43.575
foreign money, as I said before. The failure is a

120
00:07:43.608 --> 00:07:47.415
company having to relocate its strategic center in

121
00:07:47.463 --> 00:07:50.901
order to get the money, the customers, or the listing it needs.

122
00:07:51.496 --> 00:07:55.046
The European Central Bank names that risk. It says

123
00:07:55.432 --> 00:07:59.063
foreign investors often provide the additional funding European

124
00:07:59.063 --> 00:08:02.726
scale-ups need and that they may increase the

125
00:08:02.726 --> 00:08:06.116
likelihood of headquarters relocating. May

126
00:08:06.695 --> 00:08:10.261
is the important word. Whether it happens is exactly

127
00:08:10.615 --> 00:08:13.872
what our scorecard measures. Test number 1,

128
00:08:14.449 --> 00:08:17.525
capital. Can Europe finance its winners?

129
00:08:18.471 --> 00:08:21.964
What happened? The Scale-Up Europe Fund targets about €5

130
00:08:22.076 --> 00:08:25.890
billion. The European Commission committed €1 billion.

131
00:08:26.499 --> 00:08:30.136
EQT manages it. It invests in rounds of

132
00:08:30.168 --> 00:08:33.678
€100 million and above. In August, it

133
00:08:33.678 --> 00:08:37.379
co-led ICEYE's €1 billion financing round,

134
00:08:38.004 --> 00:08:41.518
which includes €450 million of

135
00:08:41.631 --> 00:08:45.452
primary Series F capital and a valuation

136
00:08:45.709 --> 00:08:48.824
above €10 billion. In September, Samsung

137
00:08:49.001 --> 00:08:52.421
Electronics and the Scale-Up Fund Europe co-led Mistral

138
00:08:52.694 --> 00:08:56.242
AI's €3 billion Series D.

139
00:08:57.190 --> 00:09:00.979
On the 10th of July, the EIB Group announced the

140
00:09:00.979 --> 00:09:04.752
European Tech Champion Initiative 2.0. With a

141
00:09:04.752 --> 00:09:07.687
fundraising target of up to €15

142
00:09:08.361 --> 00:09:12.130
billion. And on the 22nd of September, the

143
00:09:12.194 --> 00:09:15.771
Commission and the EIB launched an Institutional Investor

144
00:09:15.819 --> 00:09:19.652
Pact with 13 institutions saying they intend

145
00:09:19.652 --> 00:09:23.502
to invest in Germany. KfW reported that

146
00:09:23.502 --> 00:09:27.207
€2.64 billion had been invested under the

147
00:09:27.287 --> 00:09:31.104
WIN initiative at the end of 2025 against a goal

148
00:09:31.136 --> 00:09:34.804
of €12 billion by 2030. KfW counts

149
00:09:34.804 --> 00:09:38.198
investment through funds, funds of funds, direct investments,

150
00:09:38.620 --> 00:09:42.436
and debt such as venture debt. There is

151
00:09:42.534 --> 00:09:46.211
no published year-by-year schedule, so that figure tells us

152
00:09:46.356 --> 00:09:49.985
progress, not whether the WIN initiative is on

153
00:09:50.050 --> 00:09:53.121
pace. Why it matters structurally.

154
00:09:53.865 --> 00:09:57.566
There are 3 different numbers in every headline about the European Growth

155
00:09:57.599 --> 00:10:01.132
Capital: a target, is what a program aims

156
00:10:01.388 --> 00:10:04.691
for. A commitment is money promised, and

157
00:10:04.691 --> 00:10:08.009
deployment is money in a company. On the

158
00:10:08.298 --> 00:10:12.145
Scale-Up Europe fund, we searched on November 3rd the

159
00:10:12.369 --> 00:10:16.137
EIC fund page, EQT's announcement, the EIB,

160
00:10:16.698 --> 00:10:19.968
the track price. We found no published total of

161
00:10:19.984 --> 00:10:23.655
commitments beyond the Commission's €1 billion.

162
00:10:24.312 --> 00:10:27.825
That is a disclosure gap. It is not proof that the money is

163
00:10:28.001 --> 00:10:31.676
missing, but a public fund should publish its closing

164
00:10:31.708 --> 00:10:34.853
figure, and we will report if it ever does so.

165
00:10:36.121 --> 00:10:39.700
The capital test is one question: can a European company raise

166
00:10:39.732 --> 00:10:42.957
its next growth round at €100 million plus

167
00:10:43.647 --> 00:10:47.177
without investors requiring it to move its parent

168
00:10:47.177 --> 00:10:50.531
company out of Europe? Not one big round— round

169
00:10:50.949 --> 00:10:54.527
after round until the answer My answer is routinely yes.

170
00:10:55.361 --> 00:10:58.875
Europe has growth funds, but it does not yet have

171
00:10:59.051 --> 00:11:02.533
capital continuity. What would change my mind?

172
00:11:03.142 --> 00:11:06.656
If, say, by 2028, most cohort companies

173
00:11:07.169 --> 00:11:10.859
that raise again do so with a European lead or

174
00:11:10.859 --> 00:11:14.357
co-lead and without changing their parent company,

175
00:11:14.870 --> 00:11:18.609
the capital test is passing. Whether the headline

176
00:11:19.094 --> 00:11:22.266
Fund sizes say. If instead

177
00:11:22.651 --> 00:11:26.470
redomiciliation clauses— so moving headquarters

178
00:11:27.208 --> 00:11:30.914
clauses— start appearing in term sheets as a condition of the next

179
00:11:30.914 --> 00:11:34.491
round, the risk is real. What I will

180
00:11:34.588 --> 00:11:37.876
measure for every company in 2026 cohort,

181
00:11:38.518 --> 00:11:41.807
each later round, who led it and whether

182
00:11:42.304 --> 00:11:46.091
the parent company stays where it is. Test

183
00:11:46.140 --> 00:11:49.752
number 2, market. Can Europe behave like a home

184
00:11:49.752 --> 00:11:53.510
market? What happened? On the

185
00:11:53.526 --> 00:11:56.881
18th of March 2026, the Commission

186
00:11:56.978 --> 00:12:00.462
proposed EU Inc., the so-called

187
00:12:00.462 --> 00:12:03.673
28th regime, as a regulation.

188
00:12:04.219 --> 00:12:07.398
Online registration within 48 hours

189
00:12:07.993 --> 00:12:11.824
at a maximum cost of €100, with no minimum capital

190
00:12:12.099 --> 00:12:15.302
and a European employee stock option rule that defers

191
00:12:15.415 --> 00:12:18.781
taxes until shares are sold. It does

192
00:12:19.056 --> 00:12:21.727
not include a pan-European corporate tax regime.

193
00:12:23.250 --> 00:12:26.732
On the 23rd of October, the member states agreed to the

194
00:12:26.732 --> 00:12:30.485
Council's negotiation position. Registration in 2 days

195
00:12:30.776 --> 00:12:34.593
for 100 euros survives. Board-level employee participation

196
00:12:34.593 --> 00:12:38.409
follows the rule of the country where the company has its registered office. The Council

197
00:12:38.409 --> 00:12:40.674
limits the stock option tax treatment to companies

198
00:12:43.108 --> 00:12:46.848
up to 750 employees and €150 million in

199
00:12:46.864 --> 00:12:49.821
turnover, and it sets a 21-month

200
00:12:50.238 --> 00:12:54.078
implementation period after the regulation enters into force.

201
00:12:55.059 --> 00:12:58.899
The European Parliament had not adopted its position

202
00:12:58.931 --> 00:13:02.353
by late October. Reports say the Legal Affairs

203
00:13:02.530 --> 00:13:06.049
Committee vote was postponed twice in October

204
00:13:06.788 --> 00:13:10.465
over employee participation. Negotiations with the Council

205
00:13:10.577 --> 00:13:13.561
cannot start until Parliament has voted.

206
00:13:14.427 --> 00:13:18.262
Why it matters structurally: EU Inc. fixes the

207
00:13:18.262 --> 00:13:22.064
first day of company's life. Much of the cost of

208
00:13:22.064 --> 00:13:25.176
fragmentation comes later: employment law,

209
00:13:25.577 --> 00:13:29.235
payroll, local tax, sector licenses. Those

210
00:13:29.444 --> 00:13:33.214
stay national. On the stock options, the Council's limit

211
00:13:33.519 --> 00:13:37.257
could exclude larger scale-ups. What happens to options

212
00:13:37.353 --> 00:13:41.010
granted before company crosses that line is not

213
00:13:41.059 --> 00:13:44.283
yet clear, and that needs to be clarified before

214
00:13:44.283 --> 00:13:48.037
founders can plan around it. Here's

215
00:13:48.037 --> 00:13:51.774
my own arithmetic on the timeline, and it is

216
00:13:51.887 --> 00:13:55.271
an estimate, of course, not a fact. If

217
00:13:55.480 --> 00:13:59.266
Parliament votes in the coming weeks, negotiations with the

218
00:13:59.266 --> 00:14:02.957
Council run into 2027. After the

219
00:14:02.957 --> 00:14:06.682
agreement comes formal adoption, publication, and entry into

220
00:14:06.730 --> 00:14:10.343
force. Add the Council's 21 months and the

221
00:14:10.407 --> 00:14:13.602
first registration lands somewhere in

222
00:14:13.699 --> 00:14:17.022
2029. That is where my forecasts

223
00:14:17.231 --> 00:14:20.844
later in this episode comes from. What people

224
00:14:20.844 --> 00:14:24.473
get wrong: they treat EU Inc. as the market

225
00:14:24.473 --> 00:14:27.831
test. It is the entry ticket. Market

226
00:14:27.831 --> 00:14:31.326
test is whether a company in Munich can hire in Lisbon,

227
00:14:31.697 --> 00:14:34.934
sell to Warsaw, and grant equity in Vienna

228
00:14:35.176 --> 00:14:38.805
without rebuilding its legal setup each single time.

229
00:14:39.353 --> 00:14:42.968
Before the demand test, which is whether evidence is more encouraging

230
00:14:43.629 --> 00:14:46.868
than people think, a quick word from our partners.

231
00:14:52.590 --> 00:14:56.337
Startuprad.io helps selected partners reach founders, investors, and operators across

232
00:14:56.433 --> 00:14:59.828
Europe, especially Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. If you want

233
00:14:59.828 --> 00:15:03.399
to build credibility with these decision-makers, explore a partnership

234
00:15:03.447 --> 00:15:04.026
at startuprad.io/become-a-partner.

235
00:15:08.303 --> 00:15:11.874
And stay with me because after the demand test, I will give you a

236
00:15:11.939 --> 00:15:13.878
forecast you can hold me to.

237
00:15:16.090 --> 00:15:19.836
Test number 3, demand. Will you buy what it builds?

238
00:15:20.586 --> 00:15:23.707
And here I want to start with a

239
00:15:23.707 --> 00:15:27.225
counterexample to my own series. Yes, I know.

240
00:15:27.819 --> 00:15:31.577
In part 4, we called it demand without deployment. Public

241
00:15:31.577 --> 00:15:35.158
money funds the supply of innovation, but the public buyer

242
00:15:35.335 --> 00:15:38.419
does not become the customer. Now look at ICEYE.

243
00:15:38.643 --> 00:15:41.743
According to EQT's announcement,

244
00:15:42.177 --> 00:15:45.710
ICEYE already delivers sovereign satellite systems

245
00:15:46.111 --> 00:15:49.805
for 7 European governments, and it's delivered an operational

246
00:15:49.805 --> 00:15:53.564
capability to Poland less than 12 months after the

247
00:15:53.564 --> 00:15:57.081
contract was signed. ICEYE shows that European

248
00:15:57.193 --> 00:16:00.952
reference demand can work. A

249
00:16:00.952 --> 00:16:04.485
European company won European governments as customers and

250
00:16:04.582 --> 00:16:08.019
delivered it under a year. The question for

251
00:16:08.035 --> 00:16:11.826
2031 is not whether this is possible, it

252
00:16:11.826 --> 00:16:15.231
is whether it becomes routine across sectors

253
00:16:15.568 --> 00:16:18.531
for companies that are not already leaders.

254
00:16:19.599 --> 00:16:23.208
Count the repeat contracts, not the pilots. A

255
00:16:23.257 --> 00:16:26.980
pilot tells you a buyer is curious. A repeat contract

256
00:16:26.980 --> 00:16:29.363
tells you a buyer depends on you.

257
00:16:31.593 --> 00:16:35.185
What happened to the rules? On

258
00:16:35.378 --> 00:16:38.987
the 9th of September 2026, the Commission proposed the

259
00:16:38.987 --> 00:16:42.170
Public Procurement Act, one directly

260
00:16:42.866 --> 00:16:46.483
applicable regulation instead of 3 directives:

261
00:16:47.061 --> 00:16:50.497
a European preference in awarding contracts,

262
00:16:51.396 --> 00:16:54.816
simplified procurements that the Commission says will

263
00:16:54.945 --> 00:16:58.220
save public buyers time, and a minimum 30%

264
00:16:58.638 --> 00:17:01.961
weight for quality criteria, innovation among them,

265
00:17:02.347 --> 00:17:06.152
subject to the comply or explain rule. The political

266
00:17:06.168 --> 00:17:09.765
target is to conclude negotiations by the end of

267
00:17:09.781 --> 00:17:13.344
2027. So why does this matter

268
00:17:13.344 --> 00:17:16.987
structurally? The proposal does contain machinery

269
00:17:17.341 --> 00:17:20.598
meant to make procurement faster and reward

270
00:17:20.631 --> 00:17:24.017
quality. What is unproven is whether it will.

271
00:17:25.188 --> 00:17:29.008
Comply or explain lets a buyer opt out with a

272
00:17:29.056 --> 00:17:32.442
reason. Simpler procedures save time on paper.

273
00:17:32.827 --> 00:17:36.647
The test is the time from tender to deployment in

274
00:17:36.679 --> 00:17:39.648
practice. What I will measure:

275
00:17:40.772 --> 00:17:44.142
for the cohort, announced European public or industrial

276
00:17:44.142 --> 00:17:47.673
contracts and how many are repeat or framework

277
00:17:47.673 --> 00:17:51.365
contracts. At the system level, time from tender

278
00:17:51.445 --> 00:17:54.495
to operational deployment where buyers publish it.

279
00:17:55.939 --> 00:17:59.374
Test number 4, people and experience compound.

280
00:18:00.578 --> 00:18:04.093
In part 5 of the series that We argued

281
00:18:04.270 --> 00:18:07.917
that Europe produces talent, but scaling experience

282
00:18:08.222 --> 00:18:12.046
does not recycle fast enough, meaning

283
00:18:12.464 --> 00:18:16.311
employees who once scaled go back into companies

284
00:18:16.424 --> 00:18:19.982
that are scaling. The operator who took a company from

285
00:18:20.030 --> 00:18:23.681
100 to 1,000 people should become the angel,

286
00:18:24.153 --> 00:18:26.706
the founder, or the board member of the next companies.

287
00:18:27.910 --> 00:18:30.875
2 signals matter. First, employee ownership.

288
00:18:31.436 --> 00:18:34.930
Equity that employees build is what can turn

289
00:18:35.106 --> 00:18:38.824
operators into angels, which is why the scope

290
00:18:38.888 --> 00:18:42.671
of the EU stock option rule matters. Second, where

291
00:18:42.671 --> 00:18:46.389
founders and operators base themselves. Atomicos'

292
00:18:46.582 --> 00:18:50.236
2025 Founder Survey found that 15% of

293
00:18:50.252 --> 00:18:53.922
surveyed founders had moved their headquarters abroad,

294
00:18:54.275 --> 00:18:57.865
and 57% of those had moved to the United States.

295
00:18:59.262 --> 00:19:02.746
What people are getting wrong here— they count startups founded

296
00:19:03.100 --> 00:19:06.424
and visas issued. Those are inputs. The

297
00:19:06.536 --> 00:19:10.374
outcome is experienced people building the next company

298
00:19:10.406 --> 00:19:13.955
in Europe. What it will measure for the cohort:

299
00:19:14.420 --> 00:19:17.937
new companies founded by alumni of cohort

300
00:19:17.953 --> 00:19:21.486
companies and where those new companies are based. The

301
00:19:21.486 --> 00:19:24.858
baseline goes into the first annual scorecard in November

302
00:19:24.858 --> 00:19:28.645
2027. Test number 5, retention. Do

303
00:19:28.645 --> 00:19:31.935
the winners stay? This is capital gravity

304
00:19:32.400 --> 00:19:36.171
turned into a scorecard line, and I want to be precise about it.

305
00:19:36.893 --> 00:19:40.359
Some good news first. EY reports that European IPO

306
00:19:40.439 --> 00:19:43.520
numbers rose 35% and proceeds

307
00:19:43.728 --> 00:19:47.467
28% in the first 3 quarters of 2026

308
00:19:47.884 --> 00:19:51.430
compared with the previous year. On the 8th of

309
00:19:51.430 --> 00:19:55.072
October, the council agreed a position agreed-to position

310
00:19:55.425 --> 00:19:59.161
that would move supervision of largest trading venues

311
00:19:59.273 --> 00:20:02.929
and post-trade infrastructure to the European Securities

312
00:20:03.025 --> 00:20:06.729
Regulator, ESMA. Now the position—

313
00:20:08.172 --> 00:20:11.988
we score retention as 4 separate indicators,

314
00:20:12.806 --> 00:20:15.997
not simply one. Where's the parent company incorporated?

315
00:20:16.830 --> 00:20:20.566
Where does the chief executive work? Where is senior

316
00:20:20.662 --> 00:20:24.307
commercial leadership based? And where is the company listed

317
00:20:24.676 --> 00:20:28.115
or expected to list? A US listing

318
00:20:28.147 --> 00:20:31.811
alone is not a failure. A US sales team

319
00:20:31.859 --> 00:20:35.619
alone is not a failure. What we look for is the

320
00:20:35.699 --> 00:20:39.331
pattern— several of those moving out of Europe

321
00:20:39.700 --> 00:20:43.412
while the engineering stays. And remember the definition: a parent

322
00:20:43.412 --> 00:20:47.204
company in Zurich or London counts as European in our

323
00:20:47.204 --> 00:20:50.958
scorecard. The sequencing gap.

324
00:20:51.439 --> 00:20:54.326
Now put the 5 tests on a timeline.

325
00:20:55.048 --> 00:20:58.784
Capital arriving now. The Scaleup Europe Fund has

326
00:20:58.897 --> 00:21:01.222
been investing since August 2026.

327
00:21:02.168 --> 00:21:05.039
ETCI 2.0 is fundraising.

328
00:21:06.177 --> 00:21:09.866
The market arrives later. EU Inc. is not

329
00:21:09.866 --> 00:21:13.490
law. Parliament has not voted and the Council's

330
00:21:13.490 --> 00:21:17.325
text gives member states 21 months

331
00:21:17.486 --> 00:21:21.321
after the entry into force. Procurement reforms arrive

332
00:21:21.354 --> 00:21:25.093
later still. Agreement is targeted for the end of

333
00:21:25.109 --> 00:21:28.575
2027, and then it has to be applied.

334
00:21:29.297 --> 00:21:33.021
So many companies financed by Europe's new growth money will scale

335
00:21:33.374 --> 00:21:36.936
for some years under today's rule. Some

336
00:21:37.402 --> 00:21:41.176
will do it very well, as ICEYE shows. The

337
00:21:41.241 --> 00:21:44.987
risk is that others will need to move their

338
00:21:44.987 --> 00:21:48.765
strategic center to get the next round— the customers or

339
00:21:48.765 --> 00:21:52.455
the listing. That is the sequencing gap. It is a

340
00:21:52.520 --> 00:21:54.301
risk to test, not a verdict.

341
00:21:56.860 --> 00:21:59.336
3 scenarios for 2031.

342
00:22:00.297 --> 00:22:03.902
Scenario number 1: Sequence Europe. EU Inc.

343
00:22:04.627 --> 00:22:08.409
is agreed in '27. and becomes usable

344
00:22:08.538 --> 00:22:12.378
in '29 with employee equity that still works for

345
00:22:12.394 --> 00:22:15.785
larger companies. The procurement act is agreed and buyers

346
00:22:15.785 --> 00:22:19.352
start running repeat contracts with young companies.

347
00:22:19.866 --> 00:22:23.707
The growth funds reach their targets and keep investing through a

348
00:22:23.707 --> 00:22:27.306
downturn. In that world, most cohort companies

349
00:22:27.579 --> 00:22:30.632
pass most tests. Another

350
00:22:30.873 --> 00:22:34.455
scenario, scenario number 2. Capital First Europe, the funds

351
00:22:34.488 --> 00:22:38.004
deploy, but market rules stays national in practice.

352
00:22:38.646 --> 00:22:42.243
Europe gets more large rounds, and a meaningful share of

353
00:22:42.339 --> 00:22:46.129
cohort companies move their parent company or leadership abroad to

354
00:22:46.129 --> 00:22:49.645
reach the next stage. The capital test improves, the

355
00:22:49.645 --> 00:22:53.483
retention test does not. And on today's legislative

356
00:22:53.515 --> 00:22:57.143
calendar, I think this scenario deserves some

357
00:22:57.143 --> 00:23:00.449
serious weight. Scenario number 3,

358
00:23:01.219 --> 00:23:04.925
stall. A downturn arrives before the instruments

359
00:23:05.053 --> 00:23:08.037
are completed. Institutional investors pull back,

360
00:23:08.599 --> 00:23:12.096
targets slip, and legislative piles lose

361
00:23:12.192 --> 00:23:15.641
priority. What separates scenario

362
00:23:16.219 --> 00:23:19.780
1 from number 2 is timing. The decision

363
00:23:19.989 --> 00:23:23.598
about where a parent company sits often comes around the later

364
00:23:23.598 --> 00:23:27.292
growth rounds or before an IPO. For companies

365
00:23:27.488 --> 00:23:30.908
raising large rounds in '27 or '26,

366
00:23:31.650 --> 00:23:35.490
that is roughly '28 to 2030. The

367
00:23:35.507 --> 00:23:37.866
window is real and is narrow.

368
00:23:40.010 --> 00:23:43.820
What would prove us wrong? Every thesis

369
00:23:43.997 --> 00:23:47.255
in this series should be falsifiable. So

370
00:23:47.932 --> 00:23:51.192
here's what would prove This one wrong.

371
00:23:52.573 --> 00:23:56.362
First, most cohort companies pass retention tests

372
00:23:56.362 --> 00:23:59.943
under today's rules. Before EU Inc. and

373
00:23:59.959 --> 00:24:03.556
procurement reforms apply, then the sequencing gap was

374
00:24:03.668 --> 00:24:07.281
not binding. Capital was enough, and I will say so

375
00:24:07.602 --> 00:24:10.733
on the show. Second, if the

376
00:24:10.797 --> 00:24:14.265
cohort shows relocations even after

377
00:24:14.265 --> 00:24:18.007
reforms are in place, then the problem was never the order of

378
00:24:18.039 --> 00:24:21.234
the instruments. It was something deeper,

379
00:24:21.716 --> 00:24:25.312
like market size or valuation, and the next part of this

380
00:24:25.344 --> 00:24:28.909
series will have to go there. Third, if

381
00:24:29.037 --> 00:24:32.650
European public and industrial buyers turn more cohort

382
00:24:32.650 --> 00:24:36.199
companies into repeat customers, as ICEYE

383
00:24:36.199 --> 00:24:39.699
shows is possible, the demand test passes and

384
00:24:39.795 --> 00:24:42.547
part 4 of this series Needs an update.

385
00:24:43.339 --> 00:24:45.972
That would be actually a good problem to have.

386
00:24:49.350 --> 00:24:52.687
Milestones we'll be watching, '27 to 2031.

387
00:24:54.847 --> 00:24:58.301
The milestones I will track, in order: next

388
00:24:58.561 --> 00:25:02.059
European Parliament's vote on EU Inc. Until that

389
00:25:02.108 --> 00:25:05.473
happens, nothing can be negotiated. January

390
00:25:05.570 --> 00:25:09.398
'27, we freeze and publish the 2026 cohort.

391
00:25:10.128 --> 00:25:13.605
In '27, Whatever the scale-up your

392
00:25:13.605 --> 00:25:16.778
fund publishes as a closing figure and whether

393
00:25:16.794 --> 00:25:20.415
ETCI 2.0 confirms the

394
00:25:20.415 --> 00:25:23.668
size of its first closing. By the end of

395
00:25:23.700 --> 00:25:27.401
'27? Whether the Public Procurement Act and the

396
00:25:27.401 --> 00:25:30.910
Savings and Investment Union supervision package are

397
00:25:30.910 --> 00:25:34.595
agreed, as the political targets say. The

398
00:25:34.595 --> 00:25:37.960
Commission is also due to report on its startup and scale-up

399
00:25:37.960 --> 00:25:41.330
strategy By the end of '27. November

400
00:25:41.330 --> 00:25:44.493
'27, 12 months out, the first annual

401
00:25:44.493 --> 00:25:48.218
scorecard for the cohort, then every November until

402
00:25:48.234 --> 00:25:51.189
2031. Forecast.

403
00:25:51.992 --> 00:25:55.749
Here's my forecast on record. No company will be able to

404
00:25:55.781 --> 00:25:59.603
register as an EU Inc. anywhere in

405
00:25:59.635 --> 00:26:02.428
the European Union before January 1st,

406
00:26:02.685 --> 00:26:06.407
2029. My confidence is 70%.

407
00:26:07.263 --> 00:26:10.914
The reason is simply the calendar. As of

408
00:26:10.914 --> 00:26:14.517
late October 26th, the European Parliament had

409
00:26:14.630 --> 00:26:18.250
not adopted its position, and negotiations with the

410
00:26:18.250 --> 00:26:20.981
member states cannot start until it does.

411
00:26:22.534 --> 00:26:26.143
This sits next to our earlier forecast,

412
00:26:26.481 --> 00:26:30.122
not instead of it. The Part 6 forecast, no EU

413
00:26:30.331 --> 00:26:34.170
Inc. before January 1st, 2028, at 75% stays on

414
00:26:34.170 --> 00:26:37.425
record. And it will be scored on that date.

415
00:26:38.307 --> 00:26:42.060
2 more predictions. First, the Scale-Up Europe Fund will

416
00:26:42.076 --> 00:26:45.251
not publicly confirm that commitments of €5

417
00:26:45.364 --> 00:26:49.020
billion or more before June 30th,

418
00:26:49.132 --> 00:26:51.987
2027. Confidence 65%.

419
00:26:52.676 --> 00:26:56.253
Second, the Public Procurement Act will not be

420
00:26:56.253 --> 00:26:59.524
formally adopted before end of '27.

421
00:27:00.021 --> 00:27:03.796
Confidence 65%. And our part 6

422
00:27:03.796 --> 00:27:07.142
forecast stays open as originally worded.

423
00:27:07.592 --> 00:27:11.062
By the end of '27, at least one scale-up fund Europe

424
00:27:11.386 --> 00:27:14.624
portfolio company will have a parent holding company

425
00:27:15.255 --> 00:27:18.878
outside of the EU. Note that this one is

426
00:27:19.233 --> 00:27:22.910
about the EU, so a Swiss or British parent

427
00:27:23.167 --> 00:27:25.407
would count. Still 60%.

428
00:27:27.437 --> 00:27:30.595
Our synthesis. So what connects all of this?

429
00:27:31.975 --> 00:27:35.682
Europe's instruments are no longer missing. Their timing is

430
00:27:35.682 --> 00:27:39.261
uneven and their effect is unproven. Each

431
00:27:39.357 --> 00:27:43.161
test depends on the others. Growth capital helps most

432
00:27:43.289 --> 00:27:47.044
when the company can also hire, sell, and grant equity

433
00:27:47.077 --> 00:27:50.334
across Europe, and when European buyers become repeat

434
00:27:50.366 --> 00:27:54.058
customers. The game changes when the

435
00:27:54.298 --> 00:27:57.986
5 tests turn green for the same companies at the same

436
00:27:58.002 --> 00:28:01.559
time. And if the cohort shows that companies

437
00:28:01.607 --> 00:28:05.052
scale globally and keep their strategic center in

438
00:28:05.181 --> 00:28:08.001
Europe under today's rules, we will say so.

439
00:28:08.866 --> 00:28:12.488
Operator and investor split. If I were

440
00:28:12.488 --> 00:28:16.062
fundraising in '27, I would do 3 things.

441
00:28:17.039 --> 00:28:20.565
I would plan my next growth rounds as a sequence and

442
00:28:20.805 --> 00:28:24.442
ask every lead investor in writing whether

443
00:28:24.827 --> 00:28:28.672
any future round assumes a change of parent company or

444
00:28:28.672 --> 00:28:32.245
listing venue. I would build an employee equity

445
00:28:32.437 --> 00:28:36.282
plan that works today across countries and can migrate

446
00:28:36.282 --> 00:28:39.246
later rather than waiting for EU Inc.

447
00:28:40.112 --> 00:28:43.797
And I would decide deliberately where my first

448
00:28:43.797 --> 00:28:47.562
large reference customer comes from. For some companies, early

449
00:28:47.642 --> 00:28:51.273
US expansion is right commercial decision. If you go to the

450
00:28:51.273 --> 00:28:55.122
US first, decide in advance which functions

451
00:28:55.557 --> 00:28:58.118
and which decision rights stay in Europe.

452
00:28:59.906 --> 00:29:03.570
If I were an investor, I would underwrite European growth rounds

453
00:29:03.957 --> 00:29:07.710
on the follow-on path, not the single check. I would

454
00:29:07.710 --> 00:29:11.086
track the full retention indicators for early growth stage

455
00:29:11.119 --> 00:29:14.673
companies separately, and I would treat the €100

456
00:29:14.673 --> 00:29:17.729
million line as the point where your

457
00:29:17.841 --> 00:29:21.453
co-investors are now present and worth bringing in early.

458
00:29:22.271 --> 00:29:26.027
If you want to go deeper, the

459
00:29:26.123 --> 00:29:29.783
Startuprad.io Founder Vault contains the working tools

460
00:29:29.960 --> 00:29:33.651
behind this episode: our Scale Infrastructure Scorecard,

461
00:29:33.651 --> 00:29:36.845
the indicators we are tracking through

462
00:29:38.242 --> 00:29:41.356
2031, and practical questions for growth

463
00:29:41.356 --> 00:29:44.980
financing and corporate location decisions. Members also

464
00:29:45.079 --> 00:29:47.534
get our analysis of targets,

465
00:29:48.690 --> 00:29:52.369
commitments, and actual capital deployment, plus the

466
00:29:52.983 --> 00:29:56.194
investor diligence checklist. Join through YouTube

467
00:29:56.372 --> 00:29:59.777
membership or Substack. Both links are

468
00:29:59.875 --> 00:30:01.846
in the show notes.

469
00:30:03.790 --> 00:30:07.419
Thank you for listening to part 8 of the European Scale-Up Question. The

470
00:30:07.451 --> 00:30:11.183
single idea to take you— to take with you A program

471
00:30:11.375 --> 00:30:15.116
is an input. A company scaling differently is an outcome.

472
00:30:15.951 --> 00:30:19.548
We have fixed the cohort rules today, so we cannot

473
00:30:19.548 --> 00:30:23.128
choose the answer later. We'll come back to this

474
00:30:23.803 --> 00:30:27.608
every November until 2031. If

475
00:30:27.672 --> 00:30:31.140
If this analysis helped, share it with a founder

476
00:30:31.188 --> 00:30:34.897
or investor facing a major growth decision. And if

477
00:30:34.897 --> 00:30:38.612
you know a European company that challenges our thesis,

478
00:30:39.722 --> 00:30:43.311
send us the evidence. Subscribe to Startuprad.io for future

479
00:30:43.424 --> 00:30:47.012
updates to the scorecard. All eight parts of the

480
00:30:47.125 --> 00:30:50.907
series are linked in the show notes. This was Startuprad.io.

481
00:30:51.132 --> 00:30:53.481
My name is Joe. Take care and see you next time. Bye.
