WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.256 --> 00:00:03.851
What happens when someone who spent more than 20 years

2
00:00:04.268 --> 00:00:08.055
helping large companies navigate crisis, change,

3
00:00:08.199 --> 00:00:11.826
and transformation suddenly moves to the other side of the

4
00:00:11.826 --> 00:00:15.404
table and starts investing her own capital into

5
00:00:15.436 --> 00:00:19.255
early-stage green tech and climate tech companies? And

6
00:00:19.352 --> 00:00:23.187
what does that tell us about the German and European

7
00:00:23.283 --> 00:00:26.556
green tech market when capital is no longer only seeking

8
00:00:26.589 --> 00:00:29.846
returns but also helping decide which

9
00:00:29.958 --> 00:00:33.192
technologies which founding teams and which

10
00:00:33.578 --> 00:00:37.331
regenerative business models get the chance to

11
00:00:37.364 --> 00:00:37.847
scale.

12
00:00:48.608 --> 00:00:52.225
Hello and welcome everybody to startuprad.io. Today

13
00:00:52.517 --> 00:00:56.005
we are speaking with Birte Kattelmann-Jagdt.

14
00:00:57.190 --> 00:01:00.443
Birte is the founder and managing director of

15
00:01:00.870 --> 00:01:04.686
Bekaya Ventures and Advisory. Before becoming a

16
00:01:04.750 --> 00:01:08.486
business angel and strategic advisor, she spent many years

17
00:01:08.935 --> 00:01:12.334
in corporate communication and strategic advisory,

18
00:01:12.927 --> 00:01:16.118
including a long career at BASF

19
00:01:16.599 --> 00:01:19.999
and later as managing director of STS Global

20
00:01:20.688 --> 00:01:23.959
and Dekelin and Advisors.

21
00:01:24.488 --> 00:01:28.208
Since 2024, she has focused on early-stage green

22
00:01:28.224 --> 00:01:31.517
tech climate tech, circular economy, and

23
00:01:31.774 --> 00:01:35.551
regenerative business models in Europe. Her investment

24
00:01:35.551 --> 00:01:38.989
approach is deliberately hands-on. She

25
00:01:38.989 --> 00:01:42.348
supports founding teams not only with capital

26
00:01:42.781 --> 00:01:45.963
but also with strategic communication, sparring,

27
00:01:46.558 --> 00:01:50.237
industry access, investor network, and transformation

28
00:01:50.253 --> 00:01:53.997
experience. In 2026, Birte was named winner

29
00:01:54.094 --> 00:01:57.049
of the BAAR Green Angels Award

30
00:01:57.708 --> 00:02:00.984
NRW, recognizing

31
00:02:01.241 --> 00:02:04.710
outstanding support for green companies through capital,

32
00:02:04.951 --> 00:02:08.581
know-how, empathy, and network access. A

33
00:02:08.645 --> 00:02:12.371
distinct part of her investment thesis is clear: she invests

34
00:02:12.580 --> 00:02:16.371
only in companies with at least one woman in the founding team.

35
00:02:16.836 --> 00:02:20.627
So today we will talk about green tech and climate tech in Europe

36
00:02:20.820 --> 00:02:23.708
female founding teams, active angel investing,

37
00:02:24.446 --> 00:02:28.072
early-stage funding, industrial transformation, and why capital

38
00:02:28.072 --> 00:02:31.619
allocation is one of the most concrete ways to shape the

39
00:02:31.619 --> 00:02:34.651
future economy. Birte, welcome to Startup Radio.

40
00:02:35.855 --> 00:02:39.273
Thank you very much. Thank you for having me. Totally

41
00:02:39.529 --> 00:02:43.364
my pleasure. Let us dive right in. You spent many years

42
00:02:43.541 --> 00:02:47.135
close to large companies— crisis communication, transformation,

43
00:02:47.328 --> 00:02:50.775
M&A, IPOs, and leadership. What made you

44
00:02:50.775 --> 00:02:54.509
move from advising transformation to financing

45
00:02:54.541 --> 00:02:57.843
transformation? Well, um, you know,

46
00:02:57.891 --> 00:03:01.641
transformation has basically been the one constant in

47
00:03:01.673 --> 00:03:05.167
everything I've done in my career. I've always

48
00:03:05.279 --> 00:03:09.094
believed that change isn't the exception, it's the normal

49
00:03:09.126 --> 00:03:12.940
condition. And first the BASF, then advising

50
00:03:13.052 --> 00:03:16.867
big corporates on crisis, M&A, and restructuring, I

51
00:03:16.899 --> 00:03:20.572
was always close to the moment where an organization had to

52
00:03:20.588 --> 00:03:24.232
reinvent itself. But at some

53
00:03:24.360 --> 00:03:28.100
point, I noticed something. Almost everything

54
00:03:28.437 --> 00:03:31.968
I was helping to manage was about optimizing what already

55
00:03:31.968 --> 00:03:35.773
existed, making the old system run faster or

56
00:03:35.821 --> 00:03:39.384
leaner. And however, you simply cannot

57
00:03:39.946 --> 00:03:43.510
solve something structural like climate change by optimizing

58
00:03:43.863 --> 00:03:47.011
legacy systems. You need to fundamentally new

59
00:03:47.091 --> 00:03:50.925
solutions. And that led to

60
00:03:50.941 --> 00:03:54.082
a very uncomfortable question for me.

61
00:03:55.048 --> 00:03:58.488
I started asking myself, am I still supporting the right

62
00:03:58.488 --> 00:04:02.149
solutions? And

63
00:04:02.278 --> 00:04:05.885
am I even on the right side of this if the corporates I'm

64
00:04:05.885 --> 00:04:08.767
advising simply aren't able to change as fast, as

65
00:04:09.202 --> 00:04:12.810
radically as the moment actually demands? And that

66
00:04:12.810 --> 00:04:16.578
question is what moved me. And because

67
00:04:16.691 --> 00:04:20.315
once you've asked it honestly, you can't keep doing the

68
00:04:20.315 --> 00:04:20.846
same thing.

69
00:04:24.816 --> 00:04:28.283
So advisory was no

70
00:04:28.446 --> 00:04:32.050
longer enough? Yeah, my

71
00:04:32.115 --> 00:04:35.440
turning point actually came with my first LP

72
00:04:35.440 --> 00:04:38.498
investment into the World Fund. That's a

73
00:04:39.059 --> 00:04:42.890
leading European climate tech fund. And through

74
00:04:42.890 --> 00:04:46.416
that, I met a female founder. I visited her at

75
00:04:46.416 --> 00:04:49.702
her pilot facility, and she said to me,

76
00:04:50.408 --> 00:04:54.158
we can still build this stage ourselves, but for the next level,

77
00:04:54.511 --> 00:04:58.246
a world-scale plant, we need help. Do you know

78
00:04:58.422 --> 00:05:02.044
anyone? And I connected her with the

79
00:05:02.044 --> 00:05:05.779
former plant director of BASF in Düsseldorf, and

80
00:05:05.972 --> 00:05:09.778
Today he supports her actually with his small

81
00:05:09.842 --> 00:05:13.504
team, a group of 4 to 5 people building that world-scale

82
00:05:13.504 --> 00:05:17.054
facility near Cologne. And after

83
00:05:17.118 --> 00:05:20.812
that happened, I thought, wow, if I

84
00:05:20.812 --> 00:05:24.330
can change so much for a startup by one

85
00:05:25.229 --> 00:05:28.570
targeted call or contact, I want more of this.

86
00:05:29.405 --> 00:05:32.719
And this is how I started mentoring scale-ups first

87
00:05:33.269 --> 00:05:36.989
on a pro bono basis alongside my

88
00:05:36.989 --> 00:05:40.289
consulting work. And then, um, that

89
00:05:40.321 --> 00:05:43.906
energized me so much that at one time I,

90
00:05:44.181 --> 00:05:47.667
I decided, okay, early 2024, I want to

91
00:05:47.667 --> 00:05:51.438
become an investor and devote my full time to startup and

92
00:05:51.488 --> 00:05:54.248
scale-up founders. So

93
00:05:55.198 --> 00:05:58.759
what did your years at BASF and in your

94
00:05:58.759 --> 00:06:02.230
strategic advisory teach you about how

95
00:06:02.422 --> 00:06:05.618
large industrial systems actually change?

96
00:06:05.971 --> 00:06:09.712
Yeah, well, the biggest thing I learned is that large industrial

97
00:06:09.841 --> 00:06:13.598
systems and organizations rarely transform from the

98
00:06:13.598 --> 00:06:16.986
inside on their own. Of course,

99
00:06:17.034 --> 00:06:20.743
corporates make their own decisions, but the trigger almost

100
00:06:20.887 --> 00:06:23.585
always comes from the outside. It's regulation,

101
00:06:24.179 --> 00:06:27.790
competition, or crisis. And the

102
00:06:27.870 --> 00:06:31.543
internal decision is real, but it's usually a response to

103
00:06:31.559 --> 00:06:35.007
external pressure that's become impossible to

104
00:06:35.023 --> 00:06:38.359
ignore. And even then, it's slower than anyone

105
00:06:38.808 --> 00:06:41.358
expects. So that may sound

106
00:06:41.358 --> 00:06:45.047
discouraging for a green tech founder, but

107
00:06:45.047 --> 00:06:48.640
it's actually, um, yeah, it's a strategic

108
00:06:48.656 --> 00:06:52.297
gift. Because if the trigger comes from the

109
00:06:52.409 --> 00:06:56.099
outside, then the trigger is visible for you. And you can watch it

110
00:06:56.099 --> 00:06:59.808
coming. A new regulation moving through Brussels,

111
00:06:59.888 --> 00:07:03.501
for example, or a competitor making a move, or a raw

112
00:07:03.501 --> 00:07:06.375
material price that's becoming a board-level problem.

113
00:07:07.178 --> 00:07:11.015
Those are the signals that a window opens,

114
00:07:11.192 --> 00:07:14.949
and you can use that, track those external drivers,

115
00:07:15.142 --> 00:07:18.690
and position yourself with your startup

116
00:07:18.995 --> 00:07:22.690
to be the solution. That's already ready and

117
00:07:22.788 --> 00:07:26.515
sitting on the shelf if the moment of pressure hits.

118
00:07:28.463 --> 00:07:31.911
And the second thing, it's rather practical.

119
00:07:32.202 --> 00:07:36.007
So in a big organization, the person who takes your first

120
00:07:36.056 --> 00:07:39.753
meeting, you are having your first meeting with, is rarely and

121
00:07:39.994 --> 00:07:41.988
almost never the person who decides.

122
00:07:43.767 --> 00:07:47.378
And with my background, I spent years learning how decisions

123
00:07:47.555 --> 00:07:51.036
actually move and who has the budget, who has veto

124
00:07:51.101 --> 00:07:54.876
power, who has to be convinced before anybody else will move.

125
00:07:55.990 --> 00:07:59.838
And so when a founder is selling into a large industrial

126
00:08:00.369 --> 00:08:03.799
corporate, I can help them map the real decision

127
00:08:03.912 --> 00:08:07.617
dynamics, dynamics, and that can really save

128
00:08:07.649 --> 00:08:08.877
months for them.

129
00:08:13.890 --> 00:08:16.099
Um, so, so basically

130
00:08:17.830 --> 00:08:21.211
Big companies

131
00:08:23.320 --> 00:08:26.460
are moved by external forces, and as a startup

132
00:08:26.476 --> 00:08:30.192
founder, green tech founder, climate tech founder, you can see that

133
00:08:30.192 --> 00:08:33.814
move earlier and be faster. Would that be a nice bottom line?

134
00:08:34.234 --> 00:08:37.874
Yeah, exactly. And let's go a

135
00:08:37.874 --> 00:08:41.239
little bit into the green tech and climate tech. When you now look at

136
00:08:41.676 --> 00:08:45.390
early-stage green tech and climate tech companies, what did you see

137
00:08:45.925 --> 00:08:49.441
that is— that like a more

138
00:08:49.489 --> 00:08:52.666
traditional financial investor might miss?

139
00:08:54.680 --> 00:08:58.529
I would love to answer this question with a moment from

140
00:08:58.529 --> 00:09:02.278
a few weeks ago. Um, many of your listeners

141
00:09:02.375 --> 00:09:05.918
may know Super Return in Berlin. That's one of the biggest

142
00:09:05.918 --> 00:09:09.750
VC conferences in the world. And there, a few weeks ago,

143
00:09:10.024 --> 00:09:13.106
an investor actually turned to me and asked is

144
00:09:13.462 --> 00:09:17.279
impact still kind of fashion? And this is

145
00:09:17.328 --> 00:09:20.750
when I almost choked my coffee, um, because I'm a

146
00:09:20.879 --> 00:09:24.681
business angel and strategic advisor for green tech startups. So my answer

147
00:09:24.681 --> 00:09:27.998
was very simple: well, I don't know

148
00:09:28.969 --> 00:09:32.763
and I don't care. And because here's the

149
00:09:32.763 --> 00:09:35.961
thing, like, the green startup community in Germany has grown

150
00:09:36.058 --> 00:09:39.757
enormously over the past 10 years, and we have now a community

151
00:09:39.854 --> 00:09:43.167
of 4,700 active companies.

152
00:09:43.904 --> 00:09:47.401
There is a reversal happening because the

153
00:09:47.593 --> 00:09:51.330
overall startup ecosystem is hitting record numbers of

154
00:09:51.378 --> 00:09:54.875
new founders, but the relative share of green startups is

155
00:09:54.907 --> 00:09:58.708
shrinking. And to, to realize this, you

156
00:09:58.756 --> 00:10:02.381
only need to have a look at the agendas of the big

157
00:10:03.006 --> 00:10:06.791
VC conferences, and it's AI, AI,

158
00:10:07.080 --> 00:10:10.872
AI, and then defense, defense. So those are the

159
00:10:10.953 --> 00:10:13.364
European big drivers right now.

160
00:10:15.410 --> 00:10:19.217
So, well, the question now can be, should a founder

161
00:10:19.298 --> 00:10:22.479
follow that trend and step back from building

162
00:10:22.527 --> 00:10:26.296
something green or social? And my clear answer is no,

163
00:10:26.457 --> 00:10:30.129
because the problems haven't gone anywhere. We are still

164
00:10:30.258 --> 00:10:33.783
consuming more finite resources than the planet has,

165
00:10:33.897 --> 00:10:37.464
and we are still emitting more than the climate can take.

166
00:10:38.377 --> 00:10:42.080
And unlike Elon Musk, I am convinced there is no Planet B.

167
00:10:42.737 --> 00:10:46.215
So what a purely financial investor can

168
00:10:46.247 --> 00:10:49.982
miss is that the most compelling green tech companies

169
00:10:50.239 --> 00:10:53.942
are trading return for values because they are

170
00:10:53.942 --> 00:10:57.485
building faster, cheaper, better versions of industrial

171
00:10:57.549 --> 00:11:01.187
processes and, and they that haven't changed in

172
00:11:01.236 --> 00:11:04.506
decades. So the founding teams in my

173
00:11:04.506 --> 00:11:08.337
portfolio, um, are the real proof. I have in our portfolio of

174
00:11:08.369 --> 00:11:12.187
10 startups and they cut greenhouse gas emissions by more than

175
00:11:12.316 --> 00:11:15.724
20— sorry, 70% versus

176
00:11:15.772 --> 00:11:19.424
conventional solutions. And they are growing. So,

177
00:11:19.682 --> 00:11:23.304
so the question was never whether we build successful impact

178
00:11:23.304 --> 00:11:25.034
startups, it's only how.

179
00:11:27.612 --> 00:11:30.895
We may add for our audience that we actually record this

180
00:11:31.105 --> 00:11:34.922
interview end of June, and I just recorded the

181
00:11:34.970 --> 00:11:37.916
startup news And really, it sounds like, uh,

182
00:11:38.703 --> 00:11:42.222
everybody, even AI, is currently drowned out by defense

183
00:11:42.318 --> 00:11:46.094
tech investment. That's, that's interesting. And it's

184
00:11:46.495 --> 00:11:50.319
of course driven by all the outside capital. Um,

185
00:11:51.621 --> 00:11:55.203
going back to the capital, you describe capital also as a

186
00:11:55.316 --> 00:11:58.417
responsibility. What does that mean in

187
00:11:58.609 --> 00:12:02.321
practice when you decide whether to invest or not?

188
00:12:03.640 --> 00:12:06.252
Yeah, what drives me is a

189
00:12:06.978 --> 00:12:10.538
profound and, and simple conviction. Uh,

190
00:12:10.828 --> 00:12:14.636
it's like our capital decides which future gets

191
00:12:14.636 --> 00:12:18.428
built, and there are very few asset classes

192
00:12:18.493 --> 00:12:22.113
where one person can shape the future as directly as in

193
00:12:22.129 --> 00:12:25.835
angel investing. You can have listed shares,

194
00:12:26.094 --> 00:12:29.693
and but there the real influence sits with big institutional

195
00:12:29.693 --> 00:12:33.029
investors. So as an angel, your capital lands

196
00:12:33.205 --> 00:12:36.654
directly where it matters. And taking that

197
00:12:36.654 --> 00:12:40.439
seriously means I don't decide on

198
00:12:40.504 --> 00:12:44.225
instinct, but 2 things are simply

199
00:12:44.225 --> 00:12:48.026
non-negotiable upfront. And that is

200
00:12:48.604 --> 00:12:51.956
one, at least one woman as an operative

201
00:12:51.988 --> 00:12:55.517
co-founder on the table with real equity and real

202
00:12:55.517 --> 00:12:59.139
vote, and generally regenerative

203
00:12:59.171 --> 00:13:02.811
core based in Europe. And the impact

204
00:13:02.811 --> 00:13:06.387
has to be built into the model. It's not a layer you can

205
00:13:06.387 --> 00:13:09.897
switch on or off. So everything past that

206
00:13:11.231 --> 00:13:15.011
gate gets the hard work. And

207
00:13:15.108 --> 00:13:18.292
that's where most of the responsibility sits.

208
00:13:19.737 --> 00:13:23.233
It's in the analysis. So questions like, is the team

209
00:13:23.233 --> 00:13:26.891
complementary and fully committed? And is there a real customer with a real

210
00:13:26.891 --> 00:13:30.318
problem? Or is it just

211
00:13:30.318 --> 00:13:33.891
encouraging conversations? And

212
00:13:34.148 --> 00:13:37.828
is there a credible path to an exit in this very

213
00:13:38.327 --> 00:13:42.023
thin climate tech market? So that's the work that

214
00:13:42.023 --> 00:13:45.614
decides it. It's far less glamorous than the

215
00:13:45.646 --> 00:13:49.076
vision. And but it's where

216
00:13:50.557 --> 00:13:54.166
I owe the founders and my own capital the

217
00:13:54.413 --> 00:13:58.037
rigor. And then almost in the end, uh, I,

218
00:13:58.502 --> 00:14:02.318
I ask one question also to myself, and this is something you

219
00:14:02.607 --> 00:14:06.182
cannot outsource to AI or any scorecard. Is it,

220
00:14:06.535 --> 00:14:09.164
am I actually the right investor for this team?

221
00:14:10.398 --> 00:14:14.198
So do I bring the network, the expertise they need

222
00:14:14.936 --> 00:14:18.367
at this specific stage? Um,

223
00:14:18.944 --> 00:14:22.776
and because writing the check is the easy

224
00:14:22.888 --> 00:14:26.619
part, and if you want to help Build the future. It's not

225
00:14:26.667 --> 00:14:30.153
about glamour, it's, uh, the rigor behind

226
00:14:30.686 --> 00:14:34.074
the check. It's usually a lot of hard work.

227
00:14:36.759 --> 00:14:40.285
I see. We've been talking there needs to be one woman in the

228
00:14:40.318 --> 00:14:44.118
founding team, so I was wondering what changes in a founding team

229
00:14:44.891 --> 00:14:48.501
when diversity is not just a communication topic

230
00:14:48.974 --> 00:14:52.533
but part of how the company makes decisions?

231
00:14:53.687 --> 00:14:57.052
Um, yeah, this criterion, the female

232
00:14:57.052 --> 00:15:00.834
founder, it's not just personal conviction for

233
00:15:00.834 --> 00:15:04.519
me, but it's also grounded in data, uh,

234
00:15:05.208 --> 00:15:08.974
any, any investor should take seriously, if you ask

235
00:15:08.990 --> 00:15:12.772
me. So we have one BCG

236
00:15:12.772 --> 00:15:16.329
study that found that for every dollar invested

237
00:15:17.163 --> 00:15:20.936
Startups with at least one female founder generated

238
00:15:20.936 --> 00:15:24.163
78%— oh, sorry, cents in revenue

239
00:15:25.110 --> 00:15:28.449
versus just 31 cents for all-male teams.

240
00:15:29.669 --> 00:15:33.377
And another report at PitchBook shows that female-founded companies reach

241
00:15:33.682 --> 00:15:36.315
exit faster on a median basis.

242
00:15:37.455 --> 00:15:41.163
In, uh, it was in 2024, they, they

243
00:15:41.227 --> 00:15:44.748
hit a record of 24 and a bit percent

244
00:15:45.167 --> 00:15:47.491
of all U.S. venture exits.

245
00:15:49.039 --> 00:15:50.879
And this is what is really striking,

246
00:15:52.955 --> 00:15:56.751
um, if you know these facts and then you

247
00:15:56.848 --> 00:16:00.495
read that only 2% of

248
00:16:00.495 --> 00:16:04.184
female founders in the U.S. still— or, um, no, it's the other way

249
00:16:04.200 --> 00:16:07.814
around— 2% of the total VC funding

250
00:16:08.089 --> 00:16:11.866
in the U.S. goes to female founders. And

251
00:16:12.206 --> 00:16:15.738
this gap is real, but it's largely ignored. And

252
00:16:16.111 --> 00:16:19.926
so, my criterion isn't charity, but

253
00:16:19.926 --> 00:16:21.290
it's a strategic edge.

254
00:16:23.607 --> 00:16:26.686
And then, your question was also about what is changing

255
00:16:27.289 --> 00:16:30.136
because of diversity. Yeah. So,

256
00:16:31.839 --> 00:16:34.807
from my experience, the team makes more balanced decisions.

257
00:16:35.956 --> 00:16:39.226
Um, I really— I have

258
00:16:39.515 --> 00:16:42.913
spoken to so many startups, and what is really

259
00:16:43.362 --> 00:16:47.081
something I observe is that all-male teams tend to produce bolder,

260
00:16:47.273 --> 00:16:51.008
more optimistic financial projections, and they sound

261
00:16:51.040 --> 00:16:54.615
great. Um, but diverse teams,

262
00:16:55.032 --> 00:16:58.799
way more perspectives, they adapt better to different

263
00:16:58.799 --> 00:17:02.470
customers, which is really important in a highly complex

264
00:17:03.255 --> 00:17:06.683
market, and they create also something what I call

265
00:17:07.140 --> 00:17:10.877
productive friction. That's the

266
00:17:11.431 --> 00:17:15.191
healthy disagreement that leads to better

267
00:17:15.191 --> 00:17:18.916
outcomes. And even if

268
00:17:18.916 --> 00:17:21.358
we're talking about green tech,

269
00:17:22.781 --> 00:17:26.323
when you're selling to large industrial corporations, then

270
00:17:26.825 --> 00:17:30.378
the ability to read a room, to adapt your message and

271
00:17:30.540 --> 00:17:34.142
build trust across very different audiences. This is really

272
00:17:34.743 --> 00:17:38.494
not a soft skill, but it's, it's a competitive advantage.

273
00:17:39.513 --> 00:17:42.734
That's a lot of interesting

274
00:17:43.883 --> 00:17:47.670
inputs. But I have to admit, from my perspective, it's also always

275
00:17:48.252 --> 00:17:51.147
very difficult to have women

276
00:17:52.052 --> 00:17:55.658
interviewed here on startuprad.io. I would love to interview

277
00:17:55.868 --> 00:17:59.654
more women, but it's, it's really hard to come by them

278
00:18:00.077 --> 00:18:03.858
as an interesting interview guest as the

279
00:18:03.874 --> 00:18:07.535
member of a founding team that actually wants to talk to me. I don't know,

280
00:18:07.711 --> 00:18:11.147
maybe I'm a little bit scary. I don't know. Um, but,

281
00:18:11.404 --> 00:18:15.033
but I, I can see where you're going. Um,

282
00:18:15.659 --> 00:18:19.175
but I do believe it's, it's a many-faceted problem there.

283
00:18:19.833 --> 00:18:23.670
Um, but let us get to other facets.

284
00:18:23.831 --> 00:18:27.218
Um, your profile connects 3 ideas: more female

285
00:18:27.234 --> 00:18:31.008
investors, more female founders, and more

286
00:18:31.473 --> 00:18:34.893
regenerative economies. What is the connection between

287
00:18:35.391 --> 00:18:38.875
all those 3? Yeah,

288
00:18:39.020 --> 00:18:42.617
people often read that line— it's also my link on my

289
00:18:42.617 --> 00:18:45.651
LinkedIn profile— as a feel-good slogan,

290
00:18:46.647 --> 00:18:50.388
but in fact it's not. It's my selection criterion. And I can

291
00:18:50.500 --> 00:18:53.310
also tell you how this developed. Like,

292
00:18:55.342 --> 00:18:58.547
It didn't start as these 3 things. In

293
00:18:58.660 --> 00:19:02.413
fact, when I started, I had only one single

294
00:19:02.525 --> 00:19:04.949
mission and that was more regenerative business

295
00:19:04.949 --> 00:19:08.543
models and

296
00:19:08.575 --> 00:19:12.039
companies that are profitable and protect resources.

297
00:19:13.308 --> 00:19:16.578
And the female lens came later when I joined Encourage Ventures.

298
00:19:16.691 --> 00:19:20.058
That's a network of female investors and female founders.

299
00:19:20.407 --> 00:19:23.104
Um, in, in Europe. And, uh,

300
00:19:24.606 --> 00:19:27.964
and then I realized this is not just a conviction,

301
00:19:28.352 --> 00:19:31.922
it's backed by data. And, um,

302
00:19:33.757 --> 00:19:35.836
in Germany there is data that

303
00:19:37.730 --> 00:19:41.337
shows that, that green startups measurably

304
00:19:42.078 --> 00:19:45.508
bring more women into leadership. So among

305
00:19:45.701 --> 00:19:49.546
green startups founded in 2025 Women

306
00:19:49.674 --> 00:19:53.076
hold 22% of leadership roles versus just

307
00:19:53.124 --> 00:19:56.943
16% at conventional ones. So green and female

308
00:19:57.040 --> 00:20:00.586
aren't 2 separate agendas, I realized, but they travel

309
00:20:00.586 --> 00:20:03.923
together. And that's why I think of

310
00:20:04.052 --> 00:20:07.887
impact investing as in the end delivering 3

311
00:20:08.208 --> 00:20:11.850
things at once. It's more diversity, it's more

312
00:20:12.155 --> 00:20:15.461
sustainable, more regenerative models, and it's more capital

313
00:20:15.493 --> 00:20:19.117
efficiency. And, and this is not a trade-off, it

314
00:20:19.117 --> 00:20:22.694
compounds. So if people hear idealism,

315
00:20:23.759 --> 00:20:25.147
I can see the system.

316
00:20:29.136 --> 00:20:32.960
Um, that is actually your investment criteria.

317
00:20:33.024 --> 00:20:36.235
So let's talk a little bit about your

318
00:20:36.316 --> 00:20:40.084
investment decision rules. Um,

319
00:20:40.358 --> 00:20:43.820
you've screened roughly 200 companies, made 10 direct

320
00:20:43.820 --> 00:20:47.363
investments since May 2024. What usually

321
00:20:47.396 --> 00:20:51.201
separates an investable team from

322
00:20:51.265 --> 00:20:55.087
a team you pass on? Hmm. So,

323
00:20:55.360 --> 00:20:59.197
so you will not be surprised if I tell you that one of the

324
00:20:59.197 --> 00:21:02.746
first things I check when I receive a pitch deck is, is there

325
00:21:03.677 --> 00:21:07.354
a female co-founder on the core team? So on this, in

326
00:21:07.466 --> 00:21:11.079
the C-level, or with real equity and a real vote?

327
00:21:12.660 --> 00:21:16.048
And, um, if it's not there, it's a pass,

328
00:21:16.667 --> 00:21:20.475
however good the rest looks. And after that,

329
00:21:20.717 --> 00:21:24.536
a lot of it is what any experienced investor would look at.

330
00:21:24.842 --> 00:21:28.276
So a complementary team with clear roles,

331
00:21:28.809 --> 00:21:32.654
a scalable product, a large market, a sharp

332
00:21:32.654 --> 00:21:36.098
value proposition. And

333
00:21:36.518 --> 00:21:40.006
to be fair, at pre-seed, I, I don't look for a

334
00:21:40.006 --> 00:21:41.911
perfect track record or polished metrics, uh, because

335
00:21:44.331 --> 00:21:48.109
Um, yeah, none of that is

336
00:21:48.141 --> 00:21:51.370
a red flag in these early stages. It's just,

337
00:21:51.919 --> 00:21:54.553
um, it's too early. But what I

338
00:21:54.860 --> 00:21:58.562
specifically listen for in green tech is a

339
00:21:58.562 --> 00:22:01.148
bold vision for a massive market,

340
00:22:02.584 --> 00:22:06.330
and at the same time an extremely focused go-to-market

341
00:22:06.330 --> 00:22:10.150
model. Um, and the

342
00:22:10.183 --> 00:22:13.788
founders who impressed me most held both at once. A vision

343
00:22:14.223 --> 00:22:17.959
and a clear go-to-market model so they

344
00:22:18.024 --> 00:22:21.857
know exactly which first customer they are chasing,

345
00:22:22.034 --> 00:22:25.864
which industrial process they are replacing, and where—

346
00:22:25.912 --> 00:22:29.468
why their solution isn't just greener but faster,

347
00:22:29.484 --> 00:22:32.180
cheaper, and better. And

348
00:22:32.954 --> 00:22:36.680
there's— yeah, I can say there are basically 2

349
00:22:36.744 --> 00:22:40.019
things or 2 patterns that would make me pass.

350
00:22:41.548 --> 00:22:45.299
Um, the first one is the team in love, and I see that

351
00:22:45.331 --> 00:22:48.985
very often, a team that is in love with its technology but

352
00:22:49.178 --> 00:22:52.945
fuzzy on the customer. So they, they have no

353
00:22:52.945 --> 00:22:56.599
sharp first segment. They have a huge addressable market,

354
00:22:56.631 --> 00:23:00.238
but if you ask them about the customers, they would say like,

355
00:23:00.318 --> 00:23:04.165
okay, it could be 5 different industries, and, and

356
00:23:04.165 --> 00:23:07.515
they have no clear idea which one to tackle first.

357
00:23:08.082 --> 00:23:11.792
And, and in deep tech, that's common, but it's also very expensive

358
00:23:11.824 --> 00:23:15.535
not to know who exactly is your customer. And

359
00:23:16.019 --> 00:23:19.716
the second, um, yeah, is

360
00:23:19.894 --> 00:23:23.387
less visible, but it's about, uh,

361
00:23:23.775 --> 00:23:27.487
the numbers that don't survive, um, a second look.

362
00:23:28.052 --> 00:23:31.186
And it's, for example, a sales cycle for industrial

363
00:23:31.283 --> 00:23:34.404
hardware planned for 3 months, but then

364
00:23:35.038 --> 00:23:38.710
everybody knows that in reality, we will need

365
00:23:38.743 --> 00:23:42.487
12 to 18. So, this is

366
00:23:42.663 --> 00:23:45.830
also something where I would

367
00:23:46.764 --> 00:23:48.521
then tell the team that this is

368
00:23:50.391 --> 00:23:53.840
either too early for me or they just need to

369
00:23:53.840 --> 00:23:57.299
readapt and sharpen their approach.

370
00:23:57.835 --> 00:23:59.118
Then,

371
00:24:02.836 --> 00:24:06.686
You screened 200 companies, you made 10 direct investments. Let's

372
00:24:06.686 --> 00:24:10.406
talk about the conversation you then have with the founders.

373
00:24:10.471 --> 00:24:13.742
In a first conversation with those founders, what

374
00:24:14.095 --> 00:24:17.576
signals make you not lean backward but lean

375
00:24:17.832 --> 00:24:21.681
inward? What excites you there? Well, I

376
00:24:21.681 --> 00:24:25.210
have a book I really love. It's written by Tom

377
00:24:25.210 --> 00:24:28.963
Steyer, or Steyer, I don't know, uh, how to pronounce it. It—

378
00:24:29.059 --> 00:24:32.577
he's, uh, from Galvanize Climate Solutions. And his

379
00:24:32.755 --> 00:24:36.524
book is called Cheaper, Faster, Better. And

380
00:24:36.572 --> 00:24:40.147
the message of this book is really simple. It's, uh,

381
00:24:40.842 --> 00:24:44.583
as a green tech startup, it's not enough to be greener, but you need to

382
00:24:44.648 --> 00:24:48.452
be cheaper, faster, better, and smarter.

383
00:24:48.743 --> 00:24:51.864
And this also connects to

384
00:24:52.560 --> 00:24:55.715
one really, yeah, I would say big

385
00:24:56.444 --> 00:24:58.920
mistake some founders still

386
00:25:00.734 --> 00:25:04.469
do have, and, and they think that, that someone will pay a green

387
00:25:04.565 --> 00:25:07.676
premium on their product, but this is not the case.

388
00:25:08.365 --> 00:25:11.876
So if you want to be successful as an impact, uh, founder

389
00:25:12.036 --> 00:25:15.083
or a green tech founder, your product needs to be

390
00:25:15.163 --> 00:25:18.770
better, smarter, cheaper,

391
00:25:18.786 --> 00:25:22.105
faster, and greener than

392
00:25:22.457 --> 00:25:26.001
your competitors. And this is something that's— that, that

393
00:25:26.145 --> 00:25:29.688
cannot be overestimated in this context. So

394
00:25:30.780 --> 00:25:34.295
the signal that would make me lean forward is then when a founder answers

395
00:25:35.194 --> 00:25:38.999
without hesitation, not just we reduce CO2,

396
00:25:40.026 --> 00:25:43.815
but we reduce CO2 and we cut the customer's energy costs by

397
00:25:43.815 --> 00:25:47.539
30%, and we integrate into existing infrastructure

398
00:25:47.555 --> 00:25:51.344
without any retrofit, like plug and play, you know. And that's

399
00:25:51.344 --> 00:25:54.779
when I know they've, they've done the real work and this, this,

400
00:25:55.100 --> 00:25:56.609
uh, business model can be successful.

401
00:25:59.975 --> 00:26:03.746
Um, we will take a short break here. When we come back,

402
00:26:03.844 --> 00:26:07.421
we'll go deeper into what active angel investing

403
00:26:07.632 --> 00:26:11.446
really means, how Birte works with portfolio companies, why

404
00:26:11.446 --> 00:26:14.757
green tech in Germany is becoming more than climate policy,

405
00:26:15.241 --> 00:26:18.522
and what founders, investors, and industrial companies

406
00:26:18.861 --> 00:26:21.838
should understand about scaling regenerative

407
00:26:22.573 --> 00:26:23.948
business models in Europe.

408
00:26:29.594 --> 00:26:32.760
Hey guys, welcome back! Let's dive into the

409
00:26:32.760 --> 00:26:36.435
next question. Birte, you

410
00:26:36.693 --> 00:26:40.142
are not a silent investor. What does active

411
00:26:40.561 --> 00:26:44.235
angel investing mean for you on a day-to-day

412
00:26:44.767 --> 00:26:48.151
work with founders? Yeah,

413
00:26:48.863 --> 00:26:52.685
For me, smart money means I'm there when it matters,

414
00:26:53.119 --> 00:26:56.379
and not just in the investor meetings, but in

415
00:26:56.572 --> 00:26:59.752
practice. It looks completely different

416
00:27:00.491 --> 00:27:03.928
from company to company. So with one company, it means

417
00:27:04.282 --> 00:27:07.622
running a sprint, uh, on international expansion,

418
00:27:08.377 --> 00:27:12.039
and then with the next one, repositioning the whole brand

419
00:27:12.136 --> 00:27:15.492
after a pivot, or untangling

420
00:27:15.588 --> 00:27:19.166
internal roles and decision-making, uh, that, that

421
00:27:19.294 --> 00:27:23.064
were slowing them down. So it completely depends on the diff— on

422
00:27:23.064 --> 00:27:26.642
the challenges, uh, the, the startup is confronted

423
00:27:26.674 --> 00:27:30.493
with, and also based on my expertise, how I can help them.

424
00:27:31.391 --> 00:27:34.728
And, and it's, it's not a fixed service, but it's,

425
00:27:35.258 --> 00:27:38.836
it's my strategic communications experience, it's industry

426
00:27:38.932 --> 00:27:42.782
access, it's Also the willingness to ask uncomfortable

427
00:27:42.798 --> 00:27:46.367
questions, because I see my

428
00:27:46.367 --> 00:27:48.922
job really

429
00:27:50.086 --> 00:27:53.564
to help them see what they are too close to see

430
00:27:53.564 --> 00:27:56.897
themselves. Because if you're a founder, you are so much into

431
00:27:57.285 --> 00:28:00.989
it that you sometimes cannot see it. And

432
00:28:01.005 --> 00:28:04.822
also to connect them to the right people at the right

433
00:28:04.822 --> 00:28:08.046
moment. And this can be an industrial partner or

434
00:28:08.046 --> 00:28:10.102
co-investor or a customer.

435
00:28:11.574 --> 00:28:15.350
So the capital is the entry ticket, and

436
00:28:15.350 --> 00:28:17.684
the real value is everything I bring after.

437
00:28:21.750 --> 00:28:25.254
The BAAR, by the way, it means Business Angel Agentur

438
00:28:25.319 --> 00:28:28.339
Ruhr— think Rhein-Ruhr area— award

439
00:28:28.629 --> 00:28:32.059
highlighted your Mut zur Konfrontation, uh,

440
00:28:32.549 --> 00:28:35.789
meaning courage for confrontation, asking questions

441
00:28:36.857 --> 00:28:40.378
Others may avoid? What kind of questions

442
00:28:40.651 --> 00:28:44.477
do founders need from an investor even

443
00:28:44.669 --> 00:28:47.199
when they are uncomfortable?

444
00:28:49.740 --> 00:28:53.006
Well, in general, you can say that the questions that matter

445
00:28:53.006 --> 00:28:55.641
most are the ones nobody

446
00:28:56.886 --> 00:29:00.649
dares to ask because everyone around the founders are

447
00:29:00.649 --> 00:29:04.094
rather either too polite or too

448
00:29:04.192 --> 00:29:06.120
invested or too close.

449
00:29:07.870 --> 00:29:11.662
And, um, and in my experience, they fall into 3

450
00:29:11.662 --> 00:29:15.293
categories. First, it's, it's about the team. So

451
00:29:15.534 --> 00:29:18.716
it's about roles. Are the roles clear? Is

452
00:29:18.893 --> 00:29:22.332
everyone doing everything, uh, and hoping,

453
00:29:22.605 --> 00:29:26.092
or is everyone all in? Or

454
00:29:26.350 --> 00:29:29.937
sometimes even one person is a part-time founder and you

455
00:29:29.953 --> 00:29:32.112
only find out, uh, later. So, so these are the things

456
00:29:33.870 --> 00:29:37.590
you don't want to see. Uh, second is the customer.

457
00:29:38.809 --> 00:29:42.449
Do they actually know them, or did they just do market research?

458
00:29:42.561 --> 00:29:46.378
Did they really speak to them and, and really

459
00:29:46.891 --> 00:29:49.425
develop that product out of these conversations?

460
00:29:50.644 --> 00:29:54.076
Um, and also when it comes to traction,

461
00:29:54.573 --> 00:29:58.133
uh, many founders present really huge

462
00:29:58.454 --> 00:30:02.206
sales pipelines, but then it's sometimes hard to know if, if they've

463
00:30:02.206 --> 00:30:05.783
really sold this, or is it only Have you had

464
00:30:05.896 --> 00:30:09.555
encouraging conversations? And, and there is

465
00:30:10.053 --> 00:30:13.648
in fact an enormous gap between the letter of intent and the signed

466
00:30:13.680 --> 00:30:17.436
contract. And, and third, it's also about

467
00:30:17.436 --> 00:30:20.999
the assumptions. Uh, so are they aware

468
00:30:21.063 --> 00:30:24.867
about the assumptions that need to be true for their

469
00:30:24.915 --> 00:30:28.574
projections to hold? And is there any

470
00:30:28.703 --> 00:30:32.420
single assumption that if it's wrong,

471
00:30:32.453 --> 00:30:36.249
it can kill your model. And, and founders

472
00:30:36.265 --> 00:30:39.317
need an investor who asks those questions early,

473
00:30:40.545 --> 00:30:42.386
um, before, before the market does.

474
00:30:45.292 --> 00:30:48.765
Before the market does. Yeah, very wise words. Um,

475
00:30:50.661 --> 00:30:53.346
you apparently are able to ask

476
00:30:53.814 --> 00:30:57.355
uncomfortable questions, but how do you challenge a

477
00:30:57.355 --> 00:31:00.858
founder directly without damaging your

478
00:31:00.858 --> 00:31:03.895
trust? From my experience, trust is

479
00:31:03.943 --> 00:31:07.626
established before the difficult

480
00:31:07.626 --> 00:31:11.311
conversations ever happen. So

481
00:31:12.491 --> 00:31:16.258
if I've been supportive, consistently

482
00:31:16.355 --> 00:31:20.133
honest, and visibly interested

483
00:31:20.310 --> 00:31:23.959
in the founder's success, then the

484
00:31:23.959 --> 00:31:27.751
hard questions, they don't land completely different

485
00:31:29.025 --> 00:31:32.363
Or they let know they do land completely different than from someone

486
00:31:32.539 --> 00:31:36.310
who only shows up when things go

487
00:31:36.326 --> 00:31:40.097
wrong. And in

488
00:31:40.097 --> 00:31:43.274
practice, I also do something. I separate the

489
00:31:43.290 --> 00:31:46.933
observation from the interpretation. So, I

490
00:31:47.077 --> 00:31:50.094
don't say your go-to-market model is wrong.

491
00:31:51.169 --> 00:31:54.539
But I say, well, I noticed your last 3 customer

492
00:31:54.539 --> 00:31:58.205
conversations weren't in the key market. It weren't—

493
00:31:58.690 --> 00:32:02.452
it wasn't about the key market, so, so, but it was niche

494
00:32:02.646 --> 00:32:05.198
ones. So what was the reason?

495
00:32:06.913 --> 00:32:10.730
And that invites them, um, into, uh, the

496
00:32:10.730 --> 00:32:14.338
analysis instead of putting them, uh, on the defensive,

497
00:32:14.370 --> 00:32:18.082
you know. And, um, and I'm also

498
00:32:18.163 --> 00:32:21.502
always transparent about my own uncertainty, so

499
00:32:22.283 --> 00:32:26.127
I only say, this is what I see and this is what

500
00:32:26.401 --> 00:32:30.197
worries me and I might be wrong and can you explain it to me?

501
00:32:31.767 --> 00:32:35.553
And so, because I'm convinced that trust isn't damaged

502
00:32:36.233 --> 00:32:38.981
by hard questions, it's

503
00:32:39.674 --> 00:32:42.982
damaged by hard questions that feel like attacks.

504
00:32:44.863 --> 00:32:48.236
And the difference is my intuition.

505
00:32:48.608 --> 00:32:52.413
So I'm very sure that founders can feel

506
00:32:52.527 --> 00:32:55.821
that. So you're the

507
00:32:55.950 --> 00:32:59.747
opposite of seagull management. When it gets difficult, they come

508
00:32:59.747 --> 00:33:02.385
in, they yell around, and then they disappear again.

509
00:33:05.310 --> 00:33:08.539
I see. Yeah, it's in fact very similar to, to

510
00:33:08.700 --> 00:33:12.219
education, to educating your, uh, your kids,

511
00:33:13.600 --> 00:33:17.126
raising your kids. They will only trust you if you've had

512
00:33:18.697 --> 00:33:22.439
some, some really warm

513
00:33:22.488 --> 00:33:24.395
and welcoming conversations before.

514
00:33:25.639 --> 00:33:29.014
Mm-hmm. I see. And they will always

515
00:33:29.127 --> 00:33:31.840
remember how you made them feel. So, so this is,

516
00:33:33.975 --> 00:33:37.372
I think, true for, for any, any personal

517
00:33:37.372 --> 00:33:41.183
relationship. I've also learned that parenting has

518
00:33:41.183 --> 00:33:44.807
a lot to do with marketing, how you tell your kids something is. Oh yeah.

519
00:33:47.112 --> 00:33:50.928
completely different topic, but, but I, I see the parallels.

520
00:33:51.104 --> 00:33:54.680
I really do see them. Um, so let's get to the next

521
00:33:54.712 --> 00:33:58.560
question. You work with portfolio companies. Your work with portfolio

522
00:33:58.576 --> 00:34:01.943
companies includes positioning, process clarity, market

523
00:34:01.943 --> 00:34:05.438
expansion, and strategic sparing. Where can an

524
00:34:05.855 --> 00:34:09.559
angel investor create the most leverage beyond just capital?

525
00:34:10.200 --> 00:34:13.487
Well, this is, this is now based on my, my personal, uh,

526
00:34:13.872 --> 00:34:17.063
experience, um, but But it's basically,

527
00:34:17.721 --> 00:34:20.992
uh, 2 specific moments. Um, the first is

528
00:34:21.105 --> 00:34:24.793
positioning. So very early, before the company

529
00:34:24.857 --> 00:34:28.257
locks in a narrative that's hard to change, um,

530
00:34:28.899 --> 00:34:32.683
it's about how a team tells its story and shapes

531
00:34:32.812 --> 00:34:36.548
everything— which investors they attract, which customers

532
00:34:36.581 --> 00:34:40.429
take them seriously, which partnerships open up.

533
00:34:40.895 --> 00:34:44.631
And, and getting that right at the start saves enormous

534
00:34:44.743 --> 00:34:48.049
effort later. And then the,

535
00:34:48.611 --> 00:34:52.061
the second leverage point is, um, is

536
00:34:52.061 --> 00:34:55.656
about enterprise sale. We've already discussed this earlier,

537
00:34:55.672 --> 00:34:59.219
like for most green tech companies, the path to scale runs through

538
00:34:59.588 --> 00:35:03.360
large industrial customers, and that's a completely different

539
00:35:03.376 --> 00:35:06.746
game. So it's long buying cycles, it's

540
00:35:06.746 --> 00:35:10.245
complex stakeholder maps, and one wrong entry

541
00:35:10.357 --> 00:35:14.000
point can cost you a year. So if I

542
00:35:14.289 --> 00:35:17.979
can help founders navigate that, um, and

543
00:35:17.979 --> 00:35:21.606
really showing them how big companies actually decide, uh,

544
00:35:21.750 --> 00:35:25.409
that's worth, uh, far more than capital in some

545
00:35:25.521 --> 00:35:28.666
cases, and, and also how they communicate.

546
00:35:29.677 --> 00:35:33.400
And, um, so beyond that, it's the,

547
00:35:33.608 --> 00:35:37.074
it's the right introduction, the right moment that

548
00:35:37.379 --> 00:35:41.190
unlocks a specific door, and Not a network for

549
00:35:41.190 --> 00:35:44.611
its own sake. Corporate procurement

550
00:35:44.611 --> 00:35:48.376
processes also give me night terrors. Um,

551
00:35:49.217 --> 00:35:52.791
green tech is often framed as climate or

552
00:35:52.937 --> 00:35:56.711
impact. At Startup Radio.io, we increasingly

553
00:35:56.743 --> 00:36:00.257
see it as kind of an industrial

554
00:36:00.371 --> 00:36:04.169
infrastructure— energy, circularity, AI

555
00:36:04.185 --> 00:36:07.764
readiness, supply chains. and resilience. Does

556
00:36:07.876 --> 00:36:11.710
that match what you see in the sector? Yeah,

557
00:36:11.726 --> 00:36:15.399
completely. And I think that reframing is one of the

558
00:36:15.399 --> 00:36:18.864
most important shifts happening right now, also in Germany. So,

559
00:36:19.890 --> 00:36:23.563
um, for very long, greentech has positioned itself as

560
00:36:23.740 --> 00:36:27.124
mainly as a climate story, and, and the

561
00:36:27.669 --> 00:36:31.391
urgency is still real, but framing it that way

562
00:36:31.760 --> 00:36:35.561
at the moment makes it easy for traditional investors to

563
00:36:35.625 --> 00:36:38.672
treat it as a niche. And so, so

564
00:36:39.314 --> 00:36:42.970
reframing, uh, changes that. Framing it

565
00:36:43.147 --> 00:36:46.836
as an infrastructure startup changes it. And,

566
00:36:46.996 --> 00:36:50.813
and high energy costs and supply chain resilience, critical raw

567
00:36:50.925 --> 00:36:54.678
materials like, like rare earth or battery

568
00:36:54.710 --> 00:36:58.319
metals— these aren't green topics, you know.

569
00:36:58.640 --> 00:37:01.735
They are core operational challenges to any

570
00:37:01.992 --> 00:37:05.735
European, uh, a company at the moment.

571
00:37:05.944 --> 00:37:09.369
So the companies solving them aren't selling

572
00:37:09.401 --> 00:37:12.757
sustainability, they are selling competitive advantage,

573
00:37:13.356 --> 00:37:17.116
and that's a far more powerful commercial narrative right now. And it's

574
00:37:17.261 --> 00:37:19.967
the one I use also with industrial partners.

575
00:37:25.501 --> 00:37:28.878
Um, Germany of course is known for strong engineering depth.

576
00:37:29.623 --> 00:37:32.812
industrial customers, and research institutions.

577
00:37:34.042 --> 00:37:37.588
What makes Germany also a serious

578
00:37:37.750 --> 00:37:40.220
green tech and climate tech market?

579
00:37:42.790 --> 00:37:45.911
Hmm, I think Germany has, uh,

580
00:37:47.150 --> 00:37:50.354
3 things that are really, really hard to copy.

581
00:37:51.747 --> 00:37:55.557
Um, one is the engineering depth like

582
00:37:56.215 --> 00:37:59.841
decades of process knowledge in chemicals, automotive,

583
00:38:00.530 --> 00:38:04.172
and energy. And this is also based in the

584
00:38:04.172 --> 00:38:07.558
Mittelstand, which is also very special about

585
00:38:07.606 --> 00:38:11.456
Germany. And the

586
00:38:11.456 --> 00:38:15.227
second thing I would say is research infrastructure. So I'm a

587
00:38:15.227 --> 00:38:18.869
mentor to the RWTH, so the

588
00:38:19.061 --> 00:38:22.719
University of Aachen, And they are a strong

589
00:38:23.408 --> 00:38:26.744
player in engineering. The Technical University of

590
00:38:26.841 --> 00:38:29.632
Munich, the Fraunhofer Helmholtz,

591
00:38:30.530 --> 00:38:34.235
um, they are producing world-class deep tech and, uh,

592
00:38:35.261 --> 00:38:38.052
are underappreciated.

593
00:38:39.432 --> 00:38:43.265
And, and, oh, sorry, not they are underappreciated,

594
00:38:43.923 --> 00:38:47.756
but the, the regulatory market as

595
00:38:47.868 --> 00:38:48.959
a market driver is

596
00:38:51.252 --> 00:38:54.947
underappreciated. And so what do I mean by this?

597
00:38:57.740 --> 00:39:00.792
Like, German industry faces some of the most demanding

598
00:39:01.147 --> 00:39:04.765
climate and circularity requirements in the world. This is

599
00:39:04.878 --> 00:39:07.882
also true for Europe as a whole, and that

600
00:39:08.415 --> 00:39:12.064
creates a real and urgent demand. And so here

601
00:39:12.064 --> 00:39:15.835
regulation isn't a headwind necessarily

602
00:39:15.933 --> 00:39:19.660
for green tech, but it's a tailwind that's driving green tech, and this

603
00:39:19.887 --> 00:39:21.053
is really special about Germany.

604
00:39:24.357 --> 00:39:28.158
I would totally agree. And that in most international

605
00:39:28.158 --> 00:39:31.118
coverage, the deep tech entrepreneurs are still

606
00:39:31.312 --> 00:39:35.125
underappreciated— I would also second that one. Um, from

607
00:39:35.206 --> 00:39:38.964
your perspective as an angel investor, where is early-stage green

608
00:39:38.997 --> 00:39:41.227
tech funding in Germany working,

609
00:39:42.302 --> 00:39:45.836
and where does the European venture capital market

610
00:39:46.080 --> 00:39:48.796
still misunderstands these companies?

611
00:39:50.112 --> 00:39:53.579
Hmm. So I think what's working is, um,

612
00:39:54.445 --> 00:39:57.928
we do have, um, capital—

613
00:39:58.297 --> 00:40:01.988
well, capital is lacking in general in, in

614
00:40:01.988 --> 00:40:05.728
Germany when it comes to the startup ecosystem, but when it comes

615
00:40:05.760 --> 00:40:09.258
to early-stage funding, we have very interesting

616
00:40:09.371 --> 00:40:12.917
accelerators. We do have early-stage

617
00:40:13.062 --> 00:40:16.480
funds. We do have a strong angel ecosystem. System.

618
00:40:17.412 --> 00:40:20.865
So, and even corporate venture arms are getting more

619
00:40:20.945 --> 00:40:23.756
sophisticated and getting more into this, uh,

620
00:40:24.607 --> 00:40:28.398
game. But from my point of view, the core problem is the

621
00:40:28.398 --> 00:40:31.787
patient money. So, uh, this is where

622
00:40:32.172 --> 00:40:35.995
our VC system is struggling, and especially

623
00:40:36.107 --> 00:40:39.593
in hardware, energy, and industrial processes, you need longer

624
00:40:40.347 --> 00:40:43.881
investment cycles than in a typical SaaS

625
00:40:44.074 --> 00:40:47.451
deal. And, and, um, our

626
00:40:47.451 --> 00:40:51.215
VC, uh, ecosystem was calibrated

627
00:40:51.215 --> 00:40:54.127
for faster returns. And so the most capital-intensive,

628
00:40:55.230 --> 00:40:58.334
most impactful companies stay

629
00:40:58.479 --> 00:41:02.100
underserved, uh, at growth stage. And this is, uh, in,

630
00:41:02.294 --> 00:41:06.059
in Series A and B where we keep losing, uh,

631
00:41:06.156 --> 00:41:09.658
our best teams to the US. Yeah,

632
00:41:09.965 --> 00:41:13.725
we are talking about in the European scale-up gap quite a lot, and

633
00:41:13.741 --> 00:41:17.547
that's also something we see, uh, sometimes called called also

634
00:41:17.547 --> 00:41:21.202
the second Valley of Death here in Germany after Series A.

635
00:41:21.731 --> 00:41:24.729
It gets really difficult to raise funds here.

636
00:41:25.563 --> 00:41:29.394
Um, but let's stay with the green techs for a little bit. Many green

637
00:41:29.426 --> 00:41:33.018
tech companies struggle when they move from early proof

638
00:41:33.258 --> 00:41:36.865
to real scale. I think you hinted already at this. Where do you see

639
00:41:37.266 --> 00:41:41.050
the biggest bottleneck there? Yeah, I think,

640
00:41:41.675 --> 00:41:45.394
yeah, as you say, it's, it's a real problem, um,

641
00:41:45.619 --> 00:41:48.891
the Valley of Death, and It's usually not a

642
00:41:48.891 --> 00:41:52.500
technology problem. The tech often works. It's

643
00:41:52.500 --> 00:41:55.854
almost always a combination of, of 3 things.

644
00:41:55.902 --> 00:41:59.592
It's the capital structure. So the ticket

645
00:41:59.592 --> 00:42:03.089
sizes for scale-up are too big for most angels and,

646
00:42:03.490 --> 00:42:06.651
and too risky for most

647
00:42:06.731 --> 00:42:10.502
institutions. So there is a genuine gap in the

648
00:42:10.502 --> 00:42:13.710
€5 to €50 million range

649
00:42:14.336 --> 00:42:17.433
for hardware-heavy green tech. And

650
00:42:17.529 --> 00:42:21.269
it's also customer commitment. Um, so as I

651
00:42:22.280 --> 00:42:25.955
said, a letter of intent is not a purchase order. And,

652
00:42:26.196 --> 00:42:29.614
and many, uh, scale-ups would reach

653
00:42:30.160 --> 00:42:33.803
scale-up with great pilots, but no one actually

654
00:42:34.477 --> 00:42:37.992
is committed to buy the scaled solution from the

655
00:42:37.992 --> 00:42:41.780
corporate landscape. And, and the third one from my point

656
00:42:41.780 --> 00:42:45.407
of view is team composition. So the skills that build a

657
00:42:45.680 --> 00:42:49.069
grade pilot aren't the skills

658
00:42:49.182 --> 00:42:51.328
that, that build a world-scale facility.

659
00:42:52.740 --> 00:42:56.421
So the founders who bring in operational expertise before they

660
00:42:56.421 --> 00:42:58.415
need it are the ones who make it through.

661
00:43:03.551 --> 00:43:06.998
And obviously, you know the

662
00:43:06.998 --> 00:43:10.704
chemical industry and industrial customers well. What do

663
00:43:10.785 --> 00:43:14.340
green tech founders often misunderstand about selling

664
00:43:14.958 --> 00:43:16.485
into these large corporates?

665
00:43:19.189 --> 00:43:22.399
Um, the most common is really to know

666
00:43:23.028 --> 00:43:26.254
who is the real decision maker in the large corporation.

667
00:43:28.260 --> 00:43:31.752
Um, so founders often optimize for the most

668
00:43:31.768 --> 00:43:35.486
enthusiastic person in the room, the innovation manager or the

669
00:43:35.486 --> 00:43:38.817
sustainability lead, the person who has invited them.

670
00:43:39.772 --> 00:43:43.576
But that person rarely controls, uh, the

671
00:43:43.592 --> 00:43:47.291
budget or the final call. And

672
00:43:47.405 --> 00:43:49.803
the, and the second is, uh, the timeline.

673
00:43:51.670 --> 00:43:55.052
Enterprise sales cycles in chemicals are— and, and,

674
00:43:55.551 --> 00:43:59.160
or manufacturing can write— it can run 18 months or

675
00:43:59.160 --> 00:44:02.561
more. And founders who plan runway on a faster

676
00:44:02.577 --> 00:44:05.947
close really get into trouble. And I've seen that in many

677
00:44:05.979 --> 00:44:08.837
cases already. Like they are too

678
00:44:08.901 --> 00:44:12.653
optimistic how long it will take to really get that

679
00:44:12.686 --> 00:44:16.437
contract signed, and then and then they really run

680
00:44:16.470 --> 00:44:20.029
out of money literally. And the the third is proof,

681
00:44:23.035 --> 00:44:26.777
and a large industrial company won't retool a production line on a

682
00:44:26.777 --> 00:44:29.499
promising pilot. They need reliability,

683
00:44:31.300 --> 00:44:34.733
data, safety certifications, integration

684
00:44:34.733 --> 00:44:37.010
feasibility, often a reference customer in a

685
00:44:37.010 --> 00:44:40.004
comparable setting. So there is a lot to do

686
00:44:40.695 --> 00:44:44.195
to prove, um, that, that you are

687
00:44:44.227 --> 00:44:47.342
right, the right fit for these large corporations.

688
00:44:48.258 --> 00:44:51.276
And, and understanding what proof is actually required

689
00:44:52.191 --> 00:44:55.371
and building towards it, that's one of the things,

690
00:44:55.868 --> 00:44:59.433
um, that, that founders need to be aware of most.

691
00:45:05.190 --> 00:45:08.815
Um, Nordrhein-Westfalen, NRW, is

692
00:45:08.815 --> 00:45:12.635
sometimes underestimated internationally as

693
00:45:12.668 --> 00:45:16.361
a green tech region. What does the ecosystem there

694
00:45:16.959 --> 00:45:19.899
have that outsiders may not see?

695
00:45:21.902 --> 00:45:25.089
Well, you ask me now, being based in Düsseldorf,

696
00:45:25.668 --> 00:45:29.428
the capital of this beautiful region. So obviously

697
00:45:29.765 --> 00:45:33.454
I'm convinced that this is one of the most interesting industrial regions

698
00:45:33.454 --> 00:45:37.161
and transformational stories in Europe right

699
00:45:37.209 --> 00:45:40.406
now. And of course, dramatically

700
00:45:40.503 --> 00:45:43.652
underrated internationally. But

701
00:45:44.520 --> 00:45:47.637
it really has over 100 years of

702
00:45:47.749 --> 00:45:51.573
industrial competence and experience.

703
00:45:51.847 --> 00:45:55.269
And what outsiders really miss is

704
00:45:55.928 --> 00:45:58.948
the density of the industrial infrastructure

705
00:45:59.479 --> 00:46:02.338
combined with with the urgency of

706
00:46:03.077 --> 00:46:06.900
reinvention. Like, the Ruhr built its whole

707
00:46:07.189 --> 00:46:10.611
identity on coal and steel, and that legacy is

708
00:46:10.787 --> 00:46:14.353
both now the challenge but also an enormous

709
00:46:14.578 --> 00:46:18.193
opportunity. So there is existing infrastructure

710
00:46:18.353 --> 00:46:21.325
that has to be decarbonized, repurposed, or

711
00:46:21.325 --> 00:46:24.313
replaced, and companies and policymakers here

712
00:46:25.004 --> 00:46:27.959
know that this transformation isn't optional.

713
00:46:28.972 --> 00:46:32.138
And also what is really interesting

714
00:46:32.317 --> 00:46:35.882
are, yeah, like the

715
00:46:35.882 --> 00:46:39.619
ingredients that are here present.

716
00:46:39.943 --> 00:46:43.518
So we do have the University of Aachen, we do

717
00:46:43.712 --> 00:46:47.357
have the NRW Bank that is funding the

718
00:46:47.357 --> 00:46:51.033
landscape, we have an angel network that is

719
00:46:51.065 --> 00:46:51.516
growing.

720
00:46:55.177 --> 00:46:58.238
You have something that is really a,

721
00:46:59.103 --> 00:47:02.949
a cluster that of course doesn't have the

722
00:47:02.965 --> 00:47:06.459
visibility of Munich or Berlin, but for founders

723
00:47:06.571 --> 00:47:10.128
building for industrial customers, this region is

724
00:47:10.320 --> 00:47:12.997
really something— it offers something very special, uh,

725
00:47:14.022 --> 00:47:17.548
that other, other regions cannot offer. And

726
00:47:17.548 --> 00:47:20.927
it's direct access to the to the very

727
00:47:20.927 --> 00:47:23.531
customers you're trying to transform.

728
00:47:27.975 --> 00:47:31.458
We, we're getting close to the end of our interview after

729
00:47:31.458 --> 00:47:35.289
recording for like almost 50 minutes. Um, by the way,

730
00:47:36.209 --> 00:47:39.905
as we said, end of June, it has been very hot, and apparently

731
00:47:40.502 --> 00:47:44.191
the heat is still caught here in my little study.

732
00:47:44.241 --> 00:47:47.940
So sorry, guys. Um, If you had

733
00:47:48.439 --> 00:47:52.014
to give one, one piece of advice to a green tech

734
00:47:52.079 --> 00:47:55.702
founder preparing to raise from angels, what

735
00:47:55.702 --> 00:47:58.372
would they prove before the first—

736
00:47:59.505 --> 00:48:03.309
what should they prove before the first investor

737
00:48:03.309 --> 00:48:06.859
conversation? Ah,

738
00:48:07.185 --> 00:48:10.860
so the most important thing, and that it seems

739
00:48:10.860 --> 00:48:14.405
so simple But it's a— well, that's

740
00:48:14.534 --> 00:48:18.207
really the most important one, is that a real customer,

741
00:48:19.279 --> 00:48:22.635
a customer you know has a real problem,

742
00:48:23.949 --> 00:48:27.159
and that your solution is the one they'd actually pay for.

743
00:48:29.334 --> 00:48:32.866
And this is not a survey. This is not a letter of intent

744
00:48:33.126 --> 00:48:36.966
from someone who had an encouraging meeting with you.

745
00:48:37.517 --> 00:48:41.067
This is an actual conversation after talking to

746
00:48:41.570 --> 00:48:45.281
procurement or operations at an

747
00:48:45.346 --> 00:48:48.700
industrial company, and where you understand their buying

748
00:48:48.716 --> 00:48:52.450
criteria, their switching costs, and, and what proof

749
00:48:52.450 --> 00:48:55.179
they need to move forward.

750
00:48:56.822 --> 00:48:59.680
And, and everything else we can build together,

751
00:49:00.638 --> 00:49:03.366
but this part is what you need to bring.

752
00:49:06.600 --> 00:49:10.368
I was wondering What belief about investing, founders,

753
00:49:10.562 --> 00:49:14.359
or green tech have you changed

754
00:49:14.359 --> 00:49:17.843
your mind about since becoming a

755
00:49:17.843 --> 00:49:21.138
business angel there? Believe as a business angel?

756
00:49:23.719 --> 00:49:26.840
No, in general. But the trigger should have been

757
00:49:27.515 --> 00:49:31.114
you being in touch with those people or the green

758
00:49:31.291 --> 00:49:34.942
tech as a business angel. I mean, it's completely

759
00:49:34.942 --> 00:49:38.669
different perspective if you look from the outside or if you're more or less

760
00:49:38.669 --> 00:49:42.252
part of the team as a business angel. So when I

761
00:49:42.300 --> 00:49:46.049
started, uh, there have been— as a, as a

762
00:49:46.065 --> 00:49:48.849
business angel, there have been many

763
00:49:49.300 --> 00:49:50.865
startups really

764
00:49:53.156 --> 00:49:55.786
building their business models based on regulation.

765
00:49:56.930 --> 00:50:00.443
So the pitch started some somewhat like

766
00:50:01.970 --> 00:50:05.687
Okay, there will be in 2028, there

767
00:50:05.687 --> 00:50:09.373
will be this new regulation, and that is

768
00:50:09.486 --> 00:50:13.108
why we need to prepare right now because large industrial

769
00:50:13.108 --> 00:50:16.699
corporations, they need to adapt to that regulation. And this is

770
00:50:17.134 --> 00:50:20.644
now the window of opportunity.

771
00:50:22.608 --> 00:50:24.589
And this is something where I really

772
00:50:26.124 --> 00:50:27.750
didn't audit

773
00:50:29.537 --> 00:50:33.385
pass because I, I simply believe

774
00:50:33.417 --> 00:50:37.186
that it's too risky to invest in something that is based on,

775
00:50:37.525 --> 00:50:41.041
on pure regulation. And this proved— it

776
00:50:41.073 --> 00:50:44.264
proved— the story proved me right because

777
00:50:44.619 --> 00:50:47.710
now we see, like, with some regulations that

778
00:50:47.903 --> 00:50:51.590
didn't come, we see many

779
00:50:51.622 --> 00:50:54.944
startups that, that didn't survive that, uh,

780
00:50:55.361 --> 00:50:59.030
this pivot in, in regulation that we've seen in the last

781
00:50:59.030 --> 00:51:02.859
years. So, so this would be my take, like, don't

782
00:51:02.875 --> 00:51:06.704
invest in something that is purely based on regulation. And

783
00:51:06.720 --> 00:51:10.518
the other thing that I've learned is really when

784
00:51:10.630 --> 00:51:14.235
you start early-stage investing in, in startups, uh,

785
00:51:14.395 --> 00:51:17.375
the only thing that you see and find is, uh,

786
00:51:18.160 --> 00:51:21.926
the team and the IP. So if it's really a tech-based this

787
00:51:21.926 --> 00:51:25.757
approach. And if it's a first-of-its-kind technology, then this is what you

788
00:51:25.773 --> 00:51:29.397
have. And, uh, and then it's really important

789
00:51:29.397 --> 00:51:32.395
that the founding team really owns the IP.

790
00:51:33.549 --> 00:51:36.948
Uh, so this is also something where I, um,

791
00:51:37.493 --> 00:51:40.940
I have a clear— or this is one of my, my

792
00:51:41.245 --> 00:51:44.114
key questions when I talk to a founding team:

793
00:51:45.253 --> 00:51:48.956
do you own your IP? Because only then I can be sure that

794
00:51:48.956 --> 00:51:52.806
there won't be an issue later on in the stages. When

795
00:51:52.806 --> 00:51:56.548
we're talking about green tech, we are talking very much about framing,

796
00:51:57.768 --> 00:52:01.446
um, like, is it green tech, is it climate tech, is

797
00:52:01.478 --> 00:52:04.770
it regenerative models, is it infrastructure?

798
00:52:05.349 --> 00:52:09.042
So in fact, for me as an

799
00:52:09.107 --> 00:52:12.929
investor, I only

800
00:52:12.961 --> 00:52:16.542
care about the impact and about the, the business model.

801
00:52:16.590 --> 00:52:19.353
So I want to see impact and returns.

802
00:52:21.700 --> 00:52:25.492
And, and I, I don't care about framing. Like, if they

803
00:52:25.492 --> 00:52:29.218
say we are an energy startup, we are an infrastructure startup,

804
00:52:29.266 --> 00:52:33.059
we are an urban tech startup, we are a circular solution— so

805
00:52:33.075 --> 00:52:36.794
this is only framing. But in the end, what

806
00:52:37.085 --> 00:52:40.690
is relevant to me as an investor is the impact

807
00:52:40.981 --> 00:52:44.750
and the returns. And this

808
00:52:44.750 --> 00:52:47.392
has really changed, uh, in the, in the

809
00:52:48.517 --> 00:52:51.936
past 2 years. Our final question,

810
00:52:52.518 --> 00:52:55.186
looking 3 years ahead, what would

811
00:52:55.849 --> 00:52:59.600
need to happen for you to say, well, this

812
00:52:59.713 --> 00:53:03.559
was not only a good investment, this actually helped build

813
00:53:04.058 --> 00:53:06.454
a more regenerative economy?

814
00:53:09.104 --> 00:53:12.065
So you mean like in regulation, what would need to happen in regulation?

815
00:53:13.380 --> 00:53:16.758
Nope, just for you, whatever it is— regulation,

816
00:53:17.032 --> 00:53:20.555
business, hot summers,

817
00:53:20.733 --> 00:53:24.551
whatever it takes. Yeah, what's really,

818
00:53:24.583 --> 00:53:28.173
what's really interesting is, um, that in fact

819
00:53:28.400 --> 00:53:31.990
some of the things happening right now, like the geopolitical

820
00:53:32.022 --> 00:53:35.690
crisis that we are seeing, is helping, uh, the

821
00:53:36.915 --> 00:53:40.756
business models I tend to invest in. So just to give you

822
00:53:40.756 --> 00:53:43.515
an example, I invested in a

823
00:53:44.558 --> 00:53:47.734
food waste startup, and they are able to

824
00:53:47.766 --> 00:53:51.343
recycle food waste, and, um,

825
00:53:52.658 --> 00:53:56.508
and the end product is fertilizer. So,

826
00:53:56.604 --> 00:53:59.074
so you can put in your, uh,

827
00:54:00.197 --> 00:54:04.014
chips, your fries, uh, your fries waste

828
00:54:04.031 --> 00:54:07.590
from, uh, from the football stadium And then the

829
00:54:07.590 --> 00:54:11.332
result is a fertilizer that you can put on, use in

830
00:54:11.332 --> 00:54:12.433
your garden even.

831
00:54:15.541 --> 00:54:19.023
And the founding team, they told me that actually with

832
00:54:19.168 --> 00:54:22.732
the development of Hormuz being closed or

833
00:54:23.022 --> 00:54:26.849
almost closed and the oil prices going up,

834
00:54:26.930 --> 00:54:30.547
the gas prices going up, but also the fertilizer

835
00:54:30.547 --> 00:54:34.099
prices going up. So this is

836
00:54:34.163 --> 00:54:37.100
helping their model to being able to

837
00:54:38.423 --> 00:54:41.150
produce fertilizer at a

838
00:54:41.150 --> 00:54:44.639
competitive price, at a competitive market price.

839
00:54:47.476 --> 00:54:50.871
And so in a way, the

840
00:54:50.871 --> 00:54:54.188
challenges we are facing right now are also

841
00:54:54.269 --> 00:54:57.053
helping the new green tech

842
00:54:57.053 --> 00:54:59.434
startups that are coming up to

843
00:54:59.708 --> 00:55:03.364
demonstrate that their models are compact, can

844
00:55:03.428 --> 00:55:06.941
be delivered at a competitive price, they are smarter, they are

845
00:55:06.973 --> 00:55:10.348
cheaper, and they're cleaner than

846
00:55:10.948 --> 00:55:14.740
what is already existing in the market. So

847
00:55:14.772 --> 00:55:17.842
this is also a

848
00:55:18.308 --> 00:55:22.150
huge opportunity for those models to grow and to

849
00:55:22.150 --> 00:55:25.599
scale in the next years to come. Birte,

850
00:55:26.068 --> 00:55:29.833
thank you for joining us. My final question is this: if founders,

851
00:55:29.866 --> 00:55:33.060
investors, and corporate decision makers remember only one

852
00:55:33.720 --> 00:55:36.956
operating principle from your work, what should it be?

853
00:55:38.602 --> 00:55:42.299
If you remember one thing, then consider that

854
00:55:42.299 --> 00:55:46.013
communication always starts with clarity. So

855
00:55:46.013 --> 00:55:49.720
first you need clarity what

856
00:55:49.720 --> 00:55:51.668
to change, what to adapt.

857
00:55:53.600 --> 00:55:57.157
And then you are able to change and to

858
00:55:57.157 --> 00:56:00.396
decide on what to change. And then the

859
00:56:00.396 --> 00:56:03.113
final result is the communication.

860
00:56:06.234 --> 00:56:09.929
Because many founders, they struggle with

861
00:56:10.026 --> 00:56:13.818
communication and they don't do the

862
00:56:13.818 --> 00:56:17.399
hard work to really think about And really

863
00:56:17.480 --> 00:56:21.245
clarify who they want to win

864
00:56:21.422 --> 00:56:24.832
over with what kind of message

865
00:56:24.832 --> 00:56:28.352
and what is their

866
00:56:28.352 --> 00:56:31.890
expectation. So you need to have that

867
00:56:32.133 --> 00:56:35.844
clear first, then you are able to change the

868
00:56:35.844 --> 00:56:38.507
room. And in the end,

869
00:56:40.762 --> 00:56:44.582
you can compile a story out of What you want to

870
00:56:44.582 --> 00:56:48.307
change. And if you have

871
00:56:48.339 --> 00:56:51.422
this clear, then it's really easy to

872
00:56:52.439 --> 00:56:55.700
convince and win over almost any stakeholder

873
00:56:56.329 --> 00:56:56.749
in the room.